Move the code that generates these wrapper nodes and attributes
from postprocessReplyTool() (only called when reply tool is enabled)
to addDiscussionToolsInternal (always called).
This undoes some changes from 31c57d594a and 980b2c38bc.
Bug: T314707
Change-Id: I07ed210375d494047670015410430c087d67f21a
It turns out that using the "enableSectionEditLinks" post-cache
transform option was not a good idea, as it is also set when viewing
old revisions and in some other cases.
However, in the pre-cache parsing, we have access to getIsPreview(),
which is exactly what we want. I think we can safely do this there.
We were already using that prior to 2bc76dabd7.
Bug: T314260
Change-Id: I7f769db48eff9fa434483902a4b5ac2f5fc96b3d
We might want to delete the code that defines it in the future.
The core message is the same in most translations, and available in
100+ more languages.
Change-Id: I230e051940fdd7b89989453eccbffac804a7ddea
Rather than setting it on both the reply link and the reply button,
set it on their parent element.
Update ReplyLinksController to handle this.
Change-Id: I650e9c0ebd354a82b8f66a63c5b4c02b2e29b105
This improves the behavior when replying to these comments
and the message snippets shown in notifications.
Bug: T313097
Change-Id: Ia10400472c9e999fa526c7437a03b72461c37b74
Add the redirect check to shouldShowNewSectionTab.
Try to run cheaper checks before more expensive ones.
Depends-On: I5755863243d8ad336ad20626f439d70eb3b31f32
Bug: T312599
Change-Id: I6848e529a2537d4058613db0c3b900bc9f4f59f8
Othercontent would often contain the opening tag of the next heading /
section. By looking for the closest node with a previousSibling we can
more-reliably escape the heading.
Also, only add the initial placeholder if there's content before the
first heading. We do this by testing for any siblings before the
startContainer of the first heading -- if there are any, assume this
means there's some sort of content. (This can still result in a
placeholder with `othercontent:""` if there's only whitespace before
the first heading.)
Bug: T313850
Change-Id: I080205b74413c46d3cf3442e79276145aaa9439c
We had different logic for the empty state on pages that exist and
those that don't. For the second case, we relied on the new topic tool
becoming unavailable in some cases, but that could cause complications
elsewhere (e.g. if the page also had a custom button to add a new
section).
The new topic tool is now available regardless of the page. Instead,
the empty state is controlled separately, by the same method in both
cases.
As far as I can tell, the effect is exactly the same as before.
Change-Id: I5b36e6f027cf76dd0e3a8ee3cb5156fe1eaac8a8
Remove hacks marked as 'TEMPORARY' now that we consider the
HTML to be stable enough.
This will avoid issues with HTML/CSS being out of sync in future deployments.
Bug: T313560
Change-Id: Ie00ff38a422f241add19d500adaf22dfeee10e8c
* clock, userAvatar, speechBubble were dropped before topic
containers was merged
* Load ellipsis & edit icons on mobile only
* Load bell & bellOutline for topic subscriptions button
Change-Id: I77d1336627b564be756e3ec50b4686b8f9ac72dc
We remove the [reply] and [subscribe] links when they should not be
visible (controlled by 'enableSectionEditLinks' option, which is
disabled when previewing).
Bug: T309423
Change-Id: Ie0d3fba2c4d166daac3ea2e117a246c9584284ca
Rename ThreadItem to ContentThreadItem, then create a new ThreadItem
interface containing only the methods that we'll be able to implement
using only the persistently stored data (no parsing), then create a
DatabaseThreadItem. Do the same for CommentItem and HeadingItem.
ThreadItemSet gets a similar treatment, but it's basically only for
Phan's type checking. (This is sad.)
Change-Id: I1633049befe8ec169753b82eb876459af1f63fe8
name and id are supposed to never be null. Calling getName() or
getId() on this object would cause an exception.
Change-Id: I5f95b7d9e4ce4550b550ee758fc86f032b676731
Extracted from patchset 29...28 of If96a0df1ef.
Also adds sorting functionality to sub_created
using the existing index on sub_id.
Bug: T294162
Change-Id: Ic4702c8c5a8119d9cdb4c3c99cf110626694777f
For comments posted on or after 2022-07-12 (configurable), use a
shorter format, identical to the timestamps MediaWiki uses in URLs.
Changing the format for already existing comments would involve
difficult migrations, therefore we elect not to do it.
Bug: T304595
Change-Id: I387051a6a3a1d84cfae45c3e1516db870cc8b977
Currently the only user input in a headingItem name is the username
which can't contain a '>', so the regex can't break, but this is
fragile, and we should always do our own escaping.
Change-Id: I14e5ae2dc1e9ad7639e61b5471aa9ce270137960
Change the HeadingItem constructor to take a 'null' headingLevel
and store this internally with the constant. Change the JSON
serializer to convert this back to null.
Change-Id: I27508eed75d94b99c5189548919309f8da7deb75
While in many cases the class will never be sub-classed, it's easier
just to always use static:: and not worry about predicting which
classes might have problems in the future.
Change-Id: I23072a1701b5acf62bb3379a877de97627d8fcf3
Fake a placeholder heading for this, unless the first heading is already
a placeholder.
Bug: T304856
Change-Id: Icc12712f77e0c14139b289bec8cc3e0cb4834a43
Keeping them visible avoid the page shifting unpleasantly,
and makes it easier to find the option you're looking for.
Change-Id: I1e37d5d11c5a19beb799346f4e9842e836224d3a
Extensions using Phan need to be updated simultaneously with core due
to T308443.
Bug: T308718
Depends-On: Id08a220e1d6085e2b33f3f6c9d0e3935a4204659
Change-Id: Iffd8dea36f3b52181f3f3414a761d441d230b7b8
Topic subscription test is going to be all logged in users only, no
transitory enrollment conditions, so we can remove the anonymous user
handling and DB writes.
Bug: T302515
Bug: T304030
Change-Id: I5e57bb9b7958576f3a04373748331a86f4626fb5
We previously ignored them before timezone indicator (e9c401e3aa),
but they can end up in other places too, e.g. after the time.
Now we ignore them after every token. This is way overkill, but it
shouldn't hurt.
Bug: T308448
Change-Id: I20f7aaa34dba23f2a2faf1be258c1aea32ab770f
We added the limit out of abundance of caution, because we were not
sure how the table is going to grow. We can see now that it's growing
slowly and reasonably.
Bug: T294881
Change-Id: I5da444c5d070926452e96ddbbe728b9e0375e466
This is a bit slower, but reduces logic duplication, and doesn't rely
on data-mw-comment-name, which we want to get rid of.
Change-Id: I79dc0937f3fc13677deb55b413796b54b747790e
Change the order of checks to ensure that we have at least one comment
before we try comparing ranges, to avoid issues with empty headings
having collapsed ranges. It should be a tiny bit faster this way, too.
Bug: T304377
Change-Id: I59ad30cfc075dcec882e048d2d199744efec2114
Exposed as DiscussionToolsPageInfo prop threaditemshtml. It returns a
version of the output of CommentParser, lightly adjusted to provide a
nested comment structure rather than a pure flat list.
Bug: T285971
Change-Id: I2f8503d4ed740a04fb2f1e3a37ae4db649b3faba
The ParserAfterParse hook will likely be deprecated, as Parsoid can't
properly support it as-is. Luckily, DiscussionTools isn't doing
anything in ParserAfterParse that couldn't happen in the (supported)
ParserAfterTidy hook.
Bug: T303630
Change-Id: If72feb1e277c09f4ea0df339f2dd097a9b329d71
Also fix a bug where headings would be ignored while checking for
comment frames. See task for detailed explanation.
Bug: T303396
Change-Id: I6495826b4b050ea80680e0798ac6ab4497a7c09e
Phan can analyze them now and reports some issues with types.
* Add some assertions on types where we're sure that we're using an
Element or non-null, but Phan can't prove it
* Fix incorrect type hints on getFullyCoveredSiblings() and
getCoveredSiblings(), luckily it was harmless
Change-Id: I8cc12450378efa7434c4d66882378b715edd4a70
We call CommentUtils::getHeadlineNodeAndOffset() before constructing
the HeadingItem in CommentParser, so the range's startContainer
is always the headline node.
Change-Id: I2afb6ba9100e785cd91f31d82f4cea59fa8b5443
`tagName` is only defined on Element, and it returns its tag name.
`nodeName` is defined on Node, and it returns the tag name for Elements,
and a string like '#text' or '#document-fragment' for other types.
We were using both, which made it harder to reason about what types
we're dealing with.
Change-Id: I8e621e5872bdf78c84ec553cfbfcdbf0192f0589
It is friendlier for static analysis tools like Phan, which can't
infer anything from the `->nodeType === …` checks, and we were already
using it in most places.
Fix newly revealed Phan failures (and one unneeded suppression).
Change-Id: Id789f05e16a210f7ba22ca7514587c392fac0741
Added in 76289cdf73,
should no longer be needed since we switch to Parsoid's
HTML parser in 3e6ab2c4d2.
Change-Id: Ic0b7ed8089b71f2338e604f68d547759e069f0b2
When 'DiscussionToolsEnableMobile' was false, we were falling back to
the desktop configuration, rather than disabling everything.
When 'DiscussionToolsEnableMobile' was true, we were enabling the
selected features on every page, instead of only discussion pages.
Follow-up to b4f10c5638.
Bug: T302388
Change-Id: Ib4a42d5acd9da528e931c74de7a870d4be513d69
Also special-case thumbnail wrappers generated by
MediaTransformOutput::linkWrap, for compatibility with
TimedMediaHandler.
Bug: T301427
Bug: T302296
Change-Id: I7f48d8b2261507c5a33526c54109f5187d062ed3
Previously, we required a signature at the end of the comment.
This was a pretty rough heuristic that did not correctly handle
many comments that we would consider entirely properly signed
in CommentParser (e.g. comments wrapped in formatting like
<small>…</small>, comments with a post-scriptum or in parentheses,
or comments generated by various templates).
Now we process the user input using the same code that adds reply
links, and only add a signature when we detect that there really
isn't a signature (including template-generated), or if the signature
is in the wrong place and would result in the reply link showing up
in the wrong place as well (not at the end of the comment).
Bug: T278442
Bug: T268558
Bug: T278355
Bug: T291421
Bug: T282983
Change-Id: I46b6110af328ebdf93b7dfc2bd941e04391a1599
Also, in ThreadItem::getSinglePageTransclusionTitle(), we don't need
this terribly complicated method.
Change-Id: If02c09aaa2f4dd66b2bc253a1edec4ea107564ee
We were rendering the preview in a completely different way from how
we would add the real reply, and the results would be different
sometimes, particularly for multi-line comments with messed-up markup.
Render it server-side instead, in a very similar way to real replies
(generating a DOM list node and transforming it through Parsoid),
although without the whole context of the page to improve performance.
We can remove a lot of client-side code that was used solely for this.
This will allow the preview to accurately display the signatures when
we change how they are added (T278442), without us having to implement
those changes again from scratch for the preview.
Change-Id: I53341f4d4075c25b67ec3b3032bff9b8a880dcd3
Goal:
-----
Finishing the work from Iadb7757debe000025e52770ca51ebcf24ca8ee66
by changing CommentParser::parse() to return a data object, instead of
the whole parser.
Changes:
--------
ThreadItemSet.php:
ThreadItemSet.js:
* New data class to access the results of parsing a discussion. Most
methods and properties are moved from CommentParser with no changes.
CommentParser.php:
Parser.js:
* parse() returns a new ThreadItemSet.
* Remove methods moved to ThreadItemSet.
* Placeholder headings are generated slightly differently, as we process
things in a different order.
* Grouping threads and computing IDs/names is no longer lazy. We always
needed IDs/names anyway.
* computeId() explicitly uses a ThreadItemSet to check the existing IDs
when de-duplicating.
controller.js:
* Move the code for turning some nodes annotated by CommentFormatter
into a ThreadItemSet (previously a Parser) from controller#init to
ThreadItemSet.static.newFromAnnotatedNodes, and rewrite it to handle
assigning parents/replies and recalculating legacy IDs more nicely.
* mw.dt.pageThreads is now a ThreadItemSet.
Change-Id: I49bfe019aa460651447fd383f73eafa9d7180a92
Goal:
-----
To have a method like CommentParser::parse(), which just takes a node
to parse and a title and returns plain data, so that we don't need to
keep track of the config to construct a CommentParser object (the
required config like content language is provided by services) and
we don't need to keep that object around after parsing.
Changes:
--------
CommentParser.php:
* …is now a service. Constructor only takes services as arguments.
The node and title are passed to a new parse() method.
* parse() should return plain data, but I split this part to a separate
patch for ease of review: I49bfe019aa460651447fd383f73eafa9d7180a92.
* CommentParser still cheats and accesses global state in a few places,
e.g. calling Title::makeTitleSafe or CommentUtils::getTitleFromUrl,
so we can't turn its tests into true unit tests. This work is left
for future commits.
LanguageData.php:
* …is now a service, instead of a static class.
Parser.js:
* …is not a real service, but it's changed to behave in a similar way.
Constructor takes only the required config as argument,
and node and title are instead passed to a new parse() method.
CommentParserTest.php:
parser.test.js:
* Can be simplified, now that we don't need a useless node and title
to test internal methods that don't use them.
testUtils.js:
* Can be simplified, now that we don't need to override internal
ResourceLoader stuff just to change the parser config.
Change-Id: Iadb7757debe000025e52770ca51ebcf24ca8ee66
The Data class contained utilities for two unrelated purposes.
Split each half to a separate class.
Notably, this improves the signature of the getLocalData() function.
Change-Id: Icde615fb9d483fee1f352c34909b37f8ffde8081
(suggested by PhpStorm)
composer.json:
* Document required PHP extensions
Parser.js:
* Remove incorrect param documentation
* Fix some typos in comments (missing parentheses)
CommentParser.php:
* Fix some typos in comments (missing parentheses)
ImmutableRange.php:
* Remove unused property
* Add a `throw` to indicate that code path is unreachable
SubscribedNewCommentPresentationModel.php:
* Add missing `return false`
CommentParserTest.php:
* Remove unnecessary pass-by-reference
CommentModifierTest.php:
* Remove unused variable
CommentParserTest.php:
* Don't construct Element objects directly. PHP's DOMElement allows
it, but Parsoid/Dodo's doesn't, and we use the latter for static
analysis. This generates all kinds of confusing warnings.
Change-Id: Ia9598ebea0e99830dd485296e94a9d96acc4b258
It adds white-space between block tags and strips invisible tags.
It may be slightly slower (it takes HTML as input rather than DOM, so
we need to serialize the HTML first and then call it, rather than only
find and concatenate text nodes), but the difference is negligible,
and it seems better to use this method than to try to re-implement it.
Test runtime went from ~9.0s to ~9.5s locally, when testing using:
php tests/phpunit/phpunit.php \
extensions/DiscussionTools/tests/phpunit/ThreadItemTest.php \
--filter getText
Bug: T219138
Change-Id: I0cb89ebd2160e1ef499b78573c6688f493a4c42f
For two given revisions, this API tells us which comments have
been added and which have been removed.
Can be used to highlight new comments, or check if the page
has been updated since we first loaded it.
Bug: T281624
Bug: T300504
Change-Id: Ia4d95ffe3b7cf2317cd8e7c0f034e09f64777ef3
It's an arbitrary limit, it seems harmless to relax it to support the
use case in the task, even if it's weird.
Bug: T300949
Change-Id: I7c895c7019726758bbae3183b9c3ecbd9eabcf38
Replaced with the more readable ::disableClientCache() method, added
in 1.38. Minimum MW version for this extension is already at 1.38.
Depends-On: I7c89e20528a0d91173f0edcb997dcae631935ee5
Change-Id: Idf1cf2fac3311f50ed3cbc420f7772b5c71b1992
This is now deployed on all wikis, and going forward I don't think
we need to make this configurable.
Change-Id: I231976267ba6cdfeec622efaa15983a84c330649
Goal: To be able to re-use or test the transformations we previously
performed in addWikitextReply() / addHtmlReply(), without requiring
a Comment object or adding the result as a reply.
Change-Id: I040c4be9b6b9bddba661f30fd0566f8850673074
* We don't need it anywhere in JS, since we're not sending that HTML
to Parsoid.
* We only need it on the nodes directly containing our reply lines in
PHP, not all over the place.
Change-Id: I0a04388225f32654dda2f599442cd27a303b5d0a
After switching from source mode to visual mode, there will be some
Parsoid-generated white space between block nodes, which remains when
the reply is posted in visual mode.
Follow-up to e064f43499.
Bug: T300439
Change-Id: Ia5d2c06f0a4125e9f148eddd3235f95138c9d37f
When we encounter a node that doesn't represent comment contents, e.g.:
* a [reply] link we inserted (T297034#7641334)
* an {{outdent}} template (see changed test case)
…we should ignore it together with its descendants (like in
Parser#nextInterestingLeafNode), instead of processing descendants
and possibly detecting comment contents in them.
Follow-up to 8de940b587,
72b9c2c6f5.
Bug: T297034
Change-Id: Ib2fa40c5fa389572b0e88ef558728fa06e3621b0
In PHP, use DOMCompat::getClassList(), provided by Parsoid.
In JS, use `.classList`, available in all supported browsers.
This may fix some bugs where we were incorrectly checking for exactly
one class. The change in isOurGeneratedNode() is needed for
Ib2fa40c5fa389572b0e88ef558728fa06e3621b0.
Change-Id: Ia28d31678fd3d617b69280c4b7857755300fa515
This code previously ensured that the fragment identifier linking
to a section was only included if all events had the same section.
It doesn't actually seem worth the effort, since we handle scrolling
to the highlighted comments client-side anyway.
And the links were not quite correct, because we didn't parse and
strip the section title as expected by built-in Echo events. Just
use Echo's code for this.
Depends-On: Idb3a87fd18330f90a8cdc1276994d54288e17b28
Change-Id: Icae0d3654dd02109337ff8737b16f55bbd514f43
The following values for configuration variables are supported:
$wgDiscussionToolsReplyIndentation = 'invisible'; (default)
$wgDiscussionToolsReplyIndentation = 'bullet';
Bug: T259864
Change-Id: Icefad79630adc6ed35687498614e6a03ede1451b
$user->saveSettings() happens in AuthManager after the LocalUserCreated
hook finishes running.
Bug: T199393
Change-Id: Ic661dbe1ffaa3a5438373a33c10ad3053662d932
Reimplement getFullyCoveredSiblings() using compareRanges(), which
checks basically the same thing, but works better and I like it more.
Bug: T297034
Change-Id: I33dc1d088bdee984064315290e378bfbfa830b10
Previously: 569db3603c (2020-06).
Unfortunately we've found cases where the previous implementation
doesn't work correctly, resulting in comments being added to the wrong
pages or page corruption.
Bug: T289873
Bug: T298051
Change-Id: Id867b3005ebc46906d6df852a525fcaec9e6b19b
Comment boundaries are stored as a DOM parent node plus a child index.
Because of that, inserting anything into the DOM before a comment –
such as another comment's start/end markers – would cause us to insert
subsequent comments' markers into the wrong places.
This issue didn't affect many pages, because usually any parent node
would have just one comment in it. Only pages with comment boundaries
outside of any wrappers (directly inside the root node) were broken.
Just process the list in reverse to fix this.
Bug: T298096
Change-Id: Iccffc36b71e9fcf3d72c4db2b9459d39042f7a2d
We realized that any change made to Special:Preferences will set the
beta preference even if they didn't visit the beta tab, so we can't
actually tell if manual intent was involved. As such, we'll enroll
people regardless of their beta setting -- they can disable the feature
through regular preferences if they want, and that'll be respected.
Bug: T291307
Change-Id: I8c1cbf51060012e8e68af252da84944dfcc681d8
For logged out users we store their test state and an anonymous
identifier in local storage. So long as the test is enabled, we include
these in any logging that occurs.
This is done entirely client-side, to avoid any cache issues caused by
state depending on cookies from PHP for logged out users.
Bug: T291307
Change-Id: Ib39e2f2146cdfdac9df5690ee3de75718f0f2731
The global function wfWikiID() is deprecated since 1.35 and it's usages
should be replaced with WikiMap::getCurrentWikiId().
Bug: T298059
Change-Id: Ie878a5479b7427e9ffab7d7f92ee2802997e3161
Better describes that we are checking the editor used to make
the edit, rather than descibing some virtual "location".
Change options to 'discussiontoolsapi' and 'any'.
Change-Id: I3024517e70ed61c738e4bf46a2ac7b58c975d98a
Trigger off the (absence of the) new preference for tracking topic tool
usage.
Change the name of the bucket preference so anyone who was enrolled in
the prior abtest won't find themselves re-enrolled.
Update the abtest enrollment code so it explicitly sets the preference
for the feature. This is a trade-off -- it does mean that we'll need to
special-case *unenrollment* once the abtest is disabled if we want to
just quietly revert people to the wiki's default, but it also means that
Special:Preferences will be accurate.
Bug: T291307
Change-Id: I659679e05b65fc7db05e249114e5a7de4cf55816
According to Daniel it only worked by accident, and stopped working
after de63ad823abe:
getPageByReference() used to do an opportunistic lookup by ID when given
an instance of PageIdentity -- which is correct for EventDispatcher,
but problematic in the general case, causing T296063.
The correct thing to do here is to use getPageById(), since the canonical
association between revision and page is by page ID.
Bug: T297431
Change-Id: Icc1df0c9ca5345e65ef5f8daf0815013d7db0943
The 'legacyPrimary' links will take you to the section
the comment is in and should be used when you don't have
access to comment IDs.
Bug: T296018
Change-Id: I944feb90e7c3a69f81366f42fa110c58cac26dbb
This reverts commit 99b757465a.
Reason for revert: We may never need the 'behind-overlay' setting
and it is untested and probably broken.
Bug: T295816
Change-Id: I9e128862271697ece5241d0e98727174b42f54ff
* Add a N/A value for edit counts from anonymous users
* Only oversample with $wgDTSchemaEditAttemptStepOversample if the edit
is from DiscussionTools
* Consider $wgWMESchemaEditAttemptStepOversample for oversampling
Bug: T286076
Bug: T295995
Depends-On: Ieb3f6c6e1775c1ef53747c37003b17e3634d1c44
Change-Id: I91245a61dfbde8b5ec9b2893b9170cc4d73f7b0a
When our interface initialized on a page that the current user
recently edited (using the reply tool, the full-page source editor,
or any other way), check if any new automatic topic subscriptions
were added and update the interface to reflect that.
This requires doing some API requests after the page is loaded,
because adding auto-subscriptions happens asynchronously in a
DeferredUpdate (potentially after the user is already viewing
the page with their comment saved), and depends on the contents
of the edit.
(When using the reply tool, we could avoid this API request and
replicate the logic, but that's not implemented in this commit
to keep it simple.)
Bug: T284836
Change-Id: Ic0fabda0de4ebbc5e424f49641e6b03ebb4b7e6a
Usually this isn't a problem, because the comments are marked as
template-generated and we don't allow replying to them. But we had a
special case where we were trying to skip over some invisible
elements, which was causing us to skip into the middle of the
about-group in some cases. When Parsoid sees that, it serializes the
contents twice.
Bug: T290940
Change-Id: I9fe0b8d43ab874ccef371990799f77bfc46bc954
We do something similar in CommentItem.js with a moment object.
The object can be converted to a string when required.
Change-Id: Id7221e9201db0d89c3b771574634c878c9515ca0
* Use featuresEnabled.newtopictool to decide when new topic
links might exist on the page, instead of relying on
`#ca-addsection` existing. Change the logic of that feature
flag to check if __NONEWSECTIONLINK__ is on the page.
* Render the add-topic button locally in a hook to replace
the one suppressed by onMinervaNeueTalkPageOverlay. Do so
whenever the newtopictool feature is enabled (see above).
Bug: T270537
Change-Id: I3e3f7403b3b86bb84fcb75a8833919512519b70f
This should avoid them showing up in unexpected contexts where parser
output is used (e.g. API T292345, search T294168, action=render).
Also rename some variables to be directionality-neutral.
Bug: T292345
Bug: T294168
Change-Id: Ibcac44ee10f0842e205d9dd9a7f3a935ce0c690b
* Explode boundary point tuples passed to computePosition
* Note that we won't use previousSibling instead of array_reverse
* Simplify logic using xor
Change-Id: I927256e31b5e441aade91b4fd0d83d8f0d89afbe
This doesn't sort by the topic name, but the hidden
sub_id field, leading to a confusing order.
Bug: T273342
Change-Id: I6146abf05544d40c9ef0d2e8c58d020e5a5fa8a2
We always do our processing in the parser now, so we don't need the
marker comment to detect whether we've already processed the page.
Bonus: include the time taken by our processing in the limit report.
Bug: T291831
Change-Id: Ife7ddffbad1b1495b004739212002a98fdebe6c0
The PHP DOM extension measures lengths and offsets in Unicode codepoints.
Our PHP code used UTF-8 bytes, causing some offsets to be slightly off.
Now it mostly uses Unicode codepoints as well (we're forced to use bytes
in a few places, because preg_match returns offsets in bytes).
In practice, this had no visible effect to the user. It caused the
markers `<span data-mw-comment-end="..."></span>` to be placed at
the end of their container instead of the correct position when the
timestamp contained multibyte characters (e.g. "ź" in Polish); but
the correct position is usually at the end of the container anyway.
In the test cases, the only difference is placing these markers before
a trailing line break inside `<p>...</p>` tags rather than before it.
The patch also accidentally fixes another bug, where element nodes
with no children (mostly <img>) were incorrectly excluded when calling
cloneContents(), because they were treated as if they were text nodes.
Change-Id: Iccdccf1078598f4b62cab96225e9c85a4c0e93ee
They were spread across several places, and some of them were checking
different things, causing us to show the view mode on some
action=edit&redlink=1 links but without showing our empty state.
Bug: T291085
Change-Id: Id1864e58c47dbd22abb41d48e31f81318d9f94f9
If the user talk edit or mention coincides with exactly one new comment:
* Change the primary link to be a direct link to the comment
* Add a text snippet to notifications that don't already include one
(user talk edits that are not new sections).
This is done for all such notifications, regardless of whether anyone
has topic subscriptions enabled.
Bug: T281590
Bug: T253082
Change-Id: I98fbca8e57845cd7c82ad533c393db953e4e5643
Last changed in March (4a0802065c),
was only needed for about 2 weeks for compatibility with cached data.
Change-Id: I510238cb86a7b4d7ae5e8636716d1e9ca2d0e402
I guess that at some point this class was meant to convert some
timestamps, but it does not (it returns them as strings in the
database format).
Change-Id: I33ee5e8807ee686b77819ef16f43509326c60762
$user is guaranteed to be a User object.
Also, while we're here:
* Remove an unnecessary TODO. There's no need for a more specific
error message, this one is just fine, other extensions use it too.
* Replace isAnon() with !isRegistered(). It'll probably be deprecated
soon, because the new UserIdentity interface doesn't include it.
Change-Id: Ifbe98f4eccef79deee6bdb54c1bccf49807a9563
This approach is used in our new topic tool empty state code and is
much nicer. Also fix typo in a comment nearby.
Change-Id: I80755ef0960a172b0f370c36c1979a86498d6fa9
For automatic topic subscriptions, I plan to introduce a third
subscription state to indicate them. This patch includes minor tweaks
I wanted to add while working on that:
* Introduce constants instead of numbers
* Remove a TODO that doesn't seem like a good idea any more
* Remove a `"length": 1` on sub_state that did not do anything
(but it might have been meant to indicate that it was supposed
to be a boolean, which would be wrong)
Bug: T284836
Change-Id: I6e6096968ad38510102287bccd349090b6ca4280
Notifications are bundled by section, so instead of linking to the
comment, link to the section.
Additionally, add a parameter to the URL listing all the comment IDs
from the bundle, and highlight them all and scroll to the topmost one.
Having to handle both URL fragments and URL query parameters makes
this code kind of a mess :(
Also, some unexpected changes became necessary:
* EventDispatcher.php: Store the section title in events using
HeadingItem::getLinkableTitle() instead of ThreadItem::getText().
The result is mostly the same, except in case of wacky markup like
images or extension tags. We can more reliably use it to link to the
section on the page, and we already use getLinkableTitle() when
generating edit summaries in the reply tool for this reason.
* dt.init.less: Change the mix-blend-mode for the highlights from
'multiply' to 'darken', so that multiple overlapping highlights do
not look more opaque. This affects how the highlights look on
non-white backgrounds and images (they're less blue, and on darker
backgrounds entirely invisible), but it seems worth it.
Bug: T286620
Change-Id: I21bb5c003abc2747f0350d3f3af558dfb55693e9
The code (prior to d25825a754) assumed
that level 3+ headings would always follow a level 2 heading or the
placeholder heading, but we don't generate a placeholder heading if
there are no comments in section zero.
Add more tests to confirm that comments under level 3+ headings (that
are not sub-headings of level 2), and level 1 headings, are ignored
when generating notifications, and do not mess with normal headings.
Bug: T288775
Change-Id: Ic57b56752a4797cb01234f66e0ed7b849752bd70
Dependency injection is now available to actions,
extension already requires MW 1.37+
Bug: T253078
Change-Id: I473abac19ed5e6f3c6706797e91704ff635f64c6
This DOMDocument property has no effect, because we do not use
DOMDocument methods for parsing HTML, but rather DOMUtils::parseHTML()
provided by Parsoid.
Change-Id: I1d9e73e53f2d44f41cf9dcda4f06ac8647671096
This should only affect some edge cases like the project namespace (e.g.
Wikipedia:Village_pump isn't a talk page, but does get discussiontools.)
Bug: T288317
Change-Id: I509101063a1d64d09cff71a84bf48c69ab7a8c08
This includes the dtrepliedto URL functionality from
I3f81e4d77faed367606e47678b8896051982359d.
Bug: T274831
Bug: T274832
Bug: T277329
Change-Id: I035d04f30c8312b0cb42902d3bf940df1482ffb3
Use `DOMCompat::getBody( ... )` as a nicer getter than
`->getElementsByTagName( 'body' )->item( 0 )`.
Remove overly defensive checks and redundant annotations on its
return value. Since we're dealing with HTML documents throughout,
the document body is guaranteed to exist.
We previously needed some of them to convince Phan when it thought
the body may be null, but this seems to no longer be needed.
Change-Id: If7aee7b6adbfa78269c7ba28b26a6eaa21fe935b
Use DOMCompat::querySelectorAll() instead.
CommentModifier::isHtmlSigned()
* Copied the CSS selector from the JS equivalent function.
CommentUtils::unwrapParsoidSections()
* Copied the CSS selector from the JS equivalent function (in VisualEditor).
CommentItem::getMentions()
* Trivial.
This causes Phan to report some more issues, which are also fixed.
Follow-up to 25272e7a4a.
Change-Id: Iaf1222f7114916f2eca19942c3686168899486fd
We can just use insertBefore() normally. There was never a PHP bug,
but rather a Phan bug, and it no longer affects us.
https://gerrit.wikimedia.org/r/c/mediawiki/extensions/DiscussionTools/+/596813/70/includes/ImmutableRange.php#373
This reveals a bug in CommentParser where it sometimes produces
incorrect ranges (we were incorrectly treating `false` like `null`,
hiding the issue). I'll fix it in a separate commit.
Follow-up to 25272e7a4a.
Change-Id: I4afba38f1d82ddbf8732bfe3e4d4f6ebe2f8de5d
In case 4 and case 6, no notifications are expected. In all other
cases we now get the expected notifications.
Bug: T285528
Change-Id: I9e813bb3a053bc1232783f9eae1ad75672b4fa7e
These changes ensure that DiscussionTools is independent of DOM
library choice, and will not break if/when Parsoid switches to an
alternate (more standards-compliant) DOM library.
We run `phan` against the Dodo standards-compliant DOM library,
so this ends up flagging uses of non-standard PHP extensions to
the DOM. These will be suppressed for now with a "Nonstandard DOM"
comment that can be grepped for, since they will eventually
will need to be rewritten or worked around.
Most frequent issues:
* Node::nodeValue and Node::textContent and Element::getAttribute()
can return null in a spec-compliant implementation. Add `?? ''` to
make spec-compliant results consistent w/ what PHP returns.
* DOMXPath doesn't accept anything except DOMDocument. These uses
should be replaced with DOMCompat::querySelectorAll() or similar
(which end up using DOMXPath under the covers for DOMDocument any way,
but are implemented more efficiently in a spec-compliant
implementation).
* A couple of times we have code like:
`while ($node->firstChild!==null) { $node = $node->firstChild; }`
and phan's analysis isn't strong enough to determine that $node is still
non-null after the while. This same issue should appear with DOMDocument
but phan doesn't complain for some reason.
One apparently legit issue:
* Node::insertBefore() is once called in a funny way which leans on
the fact that the second option is optional in PHP. This seems to be
a workaround for an ancient PHP bug, and can probably be safely
removed.
Bug: T287611
Bug: T217867
Change-Id: I3c4f41c3819770f85d68157c9f690d650b7266a3
For compatibility with Parsoid's document abstraction (Parsoid may
switch to an alternate DOM library in the future), don't explicitly
create a new document object using `new DOMDocument`; instead use
the Parsoid wrapper `DOMCompat::newDocument()`. This ensures that
the Document object created will be compatible with Parsoid.
There are a number of other subtle dependencies on the PHP `dom`
extension in DiscussionTools, like explicit `instanceof` tests; those
will be tweaked in a follow-up patch
(I3c4f41c3819770f85d68157c9f690d650b7266a3) since they do not affect
correctness so long as Parsoid is aliasing Document to a subclass of
the built-in DOMDocument. Similarly, the Phan warnings we suppress
do not cause runtime errors (because of the fixes included in
c5265341afd9efde6b54ba56dc009aab88eff83c) but phan will be happier
once the follow-up patch lands and aligns all the DOM types.
Bug: T287611
Depends-On: If0671255779571a91d3472a9d90d0f2d69dd1f7d
Change-Id: Ib98bd5b76de7a0d32a29840d1ce04379c72ef486
The user interface only allows you to subscribe to level 2 headings.
But we would generate events for whatever heading was the closest,
If it was e.g. level 3, no one would receive that notification.
Now we generate events for the closest level 2 heading, or we don't
generate the event at all if there isn't one (if the only headings are
of level 3 and below, or level 1, or if the comment is added before
the first heading on the page).
Bug: T286736
Change-Id: Iae99853070e353ab81c9cc29ef1d53c877adfc66
We used an internal API requests to fetch page content because it was
easy, but there's no way to guarantee that it returns data from the
primary database.
Use ParserOutputAccess::getParserOutput() to fetch from cache if
available. Also, use canonical output instead of user-specific,
not that it should matter.
Bug: T285895
Change-Id: I7dcd9659be77746dc2a0c4eeae2319887936b555
…without making the topic subscriptions feature available in user preferences.
Follow-up to these commits, which added these checks in ad-hoc ways:
* 9420f22e9d
* f3422f40a6
* 23a490deca
* a555db7892
Bug: T284491
Change-Id: If2e3fb1e06d1cc489fbca14796ed77c83bb52991
If the revision from which we generated the notification has been
deleted, we shouldn't include the content snippet, nor the direct link
to the comment (because the fragment ID is generated from the content).
This matches how Echo handles mention notifications.
Change-Id: Ica939f3a4efd39d0c295511d58280d3f9d584129
As it happens, most of Echo does not actually parse this message,
but it is for some reason parsed in HTML email notifications.
Change-Id: I414cd242d9bcc4d8b5a1c2a2a71be9e5f00ea8be
We don't display [subscribe] buttons on your user talk page,
but the API still allows those subscriptions.
Use the same approach as for mentions to ensure this doesn't cause
duplicate notifications.
Remove some code in SubscribedNewCommentPresentationModel,
now guaranteed to be unused.
Change-Id: I99a276a48d8562552ed2c54cc0323e8e428845fd
Otherwise, the global context is used (RequestContext::getMain()),
which is undesirable when you're building a rubegoldbergian
contraption and we're already inside an internal action API request
with a fake context.
Change-Id: I01daf8dc70b5751bc1e157fe598988cd5d3219e5
Per Manuel Arostegui in T263817#7033384. The limit is 5000.
(I picked it arbitrarily, there's no real rationale for it.)
Also log a warning when any user reaches half of the limit,
so that we might make a decision about changing this mechanism
before it starts affecting users. Maybe at that time we'll
have data to show that it's safe to remove the limit.
Bug: T263817
Change-Id: I18a8ee0ad7383759229c5721d5253fb591457d4d
Using `updateCacheExpiry()` in this way appears to be established
with examples of other use in WMF production such as:
- CategortyTree extension:
custom cache expiry for pages with `<categorytree>`.
- RSS extension:
custom cache expiry for pages with `<rss>`.
- intersection extension:
custom cache expiry for pages with `<DynamicPageList>`.
- Math extension:
custom cache expiry if `<math>` failed.
- Wikibase extension, Flow extension:
no caching for certain namespaces or content types.
- Graph extension, Kartographer extension:
via onParserAfterParse hook, no caching if on preview.
Bug: T280605
Change-Id: Iea41ab8599ffae4622c97d682258b1b64eaf9ba2
Previously we relied on the NamespaceInfo check below to reject
special pages, but after commit 07d885248bc54bdc0f12d9745916c794d45ec81c
in MediaWiki core, PageProps throws an exception when called with a
special page.
Bug: T281180
Depends-On: I32c94107fde96b9d6344c77b621be9b3b9b7faaf
Change-Id: I0fd893c63a6e92f6c84e7aa92270852e1137fcad
The issue occurred when replying to a comment consisting of multiple
list items, starting with a <dt> (instead of the expected <dd>), so
that the comment is considered to be unindented.
Modifier tried to add the reply directly inside the list (<dl>) rather
than inside the last list item (<dt>), which caused it to be confused
about indentation levels and try to un-indent more times than there
were indentations.
The simplest solution, given the existing code, is to add the reply
outside the list instead, in a new list. This results in a "list gap"
(<dl><dt>...</dt><dd>...</dd></dl><dl><dd>...</dd></dl>), but I think
it's acceptable for this rare case.
There are separate tests cases for old Parser and for Parsoid HTML,
because they parse the original wikitext differently (with the old
Parser producing HTML with a list gap too).
Bug: T279445
Change-Id: Ie0ee960e7090cf051ee547b480c980e9530eda51
The regexps needs to be non-greedy, otherwise it could swallow up a
large chunk of the page (up to the next comment).
I noticed this when adding tests for this code, in the 'unclosed-font'
test case (Ief9648b8805fadcc170c54b627eb669cc8b907b6).
Change-Id: I5f67a9599b0cb07bdd53abeebac9ada221181b66
If curLevel or desiredLevel are calculated incorrectly, this loop
could never end.
In JS, something would throw an exception before going infinite, but
PHP is happy to trot along despite accessing properties of null and
attaching multiple children to a document node.
Bug: T279445
Change-Id: I1784f550ec3a23dcded4f2b1def97e51cb414b7b
We added it because the initial designs for the subscribe action were
much easier to implement like this, and topic "containers" (T269950)
would have required it.
However, the latest design of the subscribe action will not need it
(T279149), and topic containers are still very far away, so let's
remove it for now.
Bug: T280433
Change-Id: I21a23e9bea43f24d265750926fbd62b99038d3f1
The 'dtenable' does not appear to take user-provided content that
requires language normalization. In general getRawVal should be used,
or if it's user input that needs normalization, use getText(). Perhaps
one day we'll alias or deprecate getVal (which is currently an odd
mid-way hybrid, most closely to getText; originally created for
EditPage.php textareas).
Change-Id: I8364c84f8c4f700da6e208df2e87c29bf254d685
We can't allow it, because the required database tables may not exist
yet (T280082).
This is meant to be temporary until we complete DBA review and the
tables are created.
Bug: T280082
Change-Id: I8f947b779c6829763d3413931c6d354e6f7aee4d
As of 7ad6328223, we also use this data
to check whether comments exist on the page, not only whether they're
transcluded.
Follow-up to 42ce942c86.
Bug: T275821
Bug: T273413
Change-Id: I95eb85354e7b84cc10ab703d28315d0667696f4c
The existing comment IDs can't be used to find the same comment on
a different revision or page (when it's transcluded), because they
depend on the comment's parent and its position on the page.
Comment names depend only on the author and timestamp. The trade-off
is that they can't distinguish comments posted within the same minute,
or in the same edit, so we will still need the IDs sometimes.
Prefer using comment names when replying, if they're not ambiguous.
This fixes T273413 and T275821.
Heading names depend on the author and timestamp of the oldest comment.
This way we don't have to detect changes to the heading text, but we
can't distinguish headings without any comments.
Bug: T274685
Bug: T273413
Bug: T275821
Change-Id: Id85c50ba38d1e532cec106708c077b908a3fcd49
Longer, but follows the style guide and less likely to conflict.
We need to account for init classes in the cache being around for
a while.
Change-Id: I738bc93393850db320fdbda2b003ca8ac40556da
Now it detect signatures generated by en.wp's {{Undated}} template,
and signatures of people who do weird stuff to the timestamps.
Bug: T275938
Change-Id: I27b07f6786ca5433a3c02a5fe68e4716d41401bb
In some cases it would return the parent node, instead of the siblings
it should return.
It's a private method only called by getFullyCoveredSiblings(), and
that method had a bug that cancelled out this one, so everything
worked correctly. But I want to use it elsewhere now and ran into it.
Change-Id: Ic12f007d57a8502a1bea5f0af17b29e9d59093d6
The horrendous 11-line if() condition did not correctly handle
signatures wrapped in inline formatting markup, like <small>.
Instead, implement this logic in the code for skipping to the end
of a paragraph, which didn't exist yet when that condition was
added, but seems like a much better place to check this now.
Bug: T275934
Change-Id: I5cccff889b5e15b5f8fde0538bf4bccb22e762cf
We may need this for topic subscriptions, and it seems
generally useful to include in the API response anyway.
Change-Id: If9522dc0c79a9a9ffb3a80f83fb17bf3c9399d6d
This code expected $container->firstChild to be a
<div class="mw-parser-output">, but that element is not present
when we're running on HTML to be saved in parser cache.
We ended up inserting the marker inside whatever node was the
first on the page, and if it was a <style> element, both our
marker and the styles would be lost when serializing, like in
6c7a0ca9a2.
When we're running on final HTML, the marker will now be outside
of <div class="mw-parser-output">, but that seems to be fine. Only
early versions of I4e60fdbc098c1a74757d6e60fec6bcf8e5db37c1 had
problems with that (see comments on patchset 41), but it works now.
The added test case also covers the fix for T274709.
Bug: T275440
Change-Id: I38d45dd8686919be51e1d307ded12b0afe185eb5
* HookUtils:FEATURES lists all features
* CommentFormatter::USE_WITH_FEATURES are all features
which require the comment formatter
Change-Id: Idbbe8bdd910b9c7b23c7fee76af7bb7ee13c2759
Going forward this will allow us to remove the parser
cache split, and toggle features just using CSS.
The CSS will be modified in a later commit to give the
anon caches time to clear.
Bug: T273072
Change-Id: I83c84b8bc63e1881e07b49acd8499b811adfccd4
I found this error in our logstash. I was not able to find an
existing Phabricator ticket.
Note how line #348 extracts the last element from the
$siblings array. It uses the function end() there, which
returns false in case the array is empty. $siblings[0] can't
do this but yields an error.
An alternative is to use reset(), which can return false as
well. But that's not really better. Especially not better
readable, I would argue.
Change-Id: Ic90cd2392ede15078ba0d5b4d67b8dc5d05f9bf7
Yes, this is still needed, removing it causes failures in tests
(and the old outputs look better).
Change-Id: I5bcedb0295a1f0ac4f6e51eaa9a9e072d8236f3c
Top-level comments that start or end with a list (inconsistent
indentation) would not have triggered the logic for detecting
wrappers.
Bug: T273692
Change-Id: Idcb4eed73e391f5f86eca2eb05cb3cea0d86f30a
* Ignore rendering-transparent nodes between discussion comments.
* Improve isRenderingTransparentNode() so that <link> nodes
representing TemplateStyles are not considered transparent,
otherwise this would undo ae920b831f.
Using a regexp from Parsoid.
Bug: T272746
Change-Id: I0b3c3251156ba6c4826abf5ba44ea93f80ebc01d
Splits the cache on the reply links feature being enabled
for a particular user and title.
An additional check is done after parsing in case the user
has the feature enabled via query string or cookie.
Bug: T267404
Depends-On: I883a37fd67108243e7a20683b1a5d59fd0f6e39f
Change-Id: I3bc06ca7d4aea7f0fe39eef0e77ad88d1f9c1043
Add yet another tree walking utility: CommentUtils::linearWalk().
Unlike TreeWalker, it allows handling the beginnings and ends of nodes
separately – kind of like parsing a XML token stream, or kind of like
VisualEditor's linear model.
(Add unit tests for this utility. The simple.html test case is copied
from [VisualEditor/VisualEditor]/demos/ve/pages/simple.html.)
Use this utility to stop skipping when we reach either a closing or
opening block node tag. Previously we'd skip over such tags inside
nested "transparent" nodes (like <a>, <del>, or apparently <font>).
Bug: T271385
Change-Id: I201a942eb3a56335e84d94e150ec2c33f8b4f4e0
The tool may go in and out of beta as new features
are release/graduated to opt-out. Users should only
need to opt in to the beta feature once to get all
future sub-features.
Bug: T272071
Change-Id: If6834b7fc07fc7e84757dc5fdcea814cd0d65936
Don't assume a feature is available because the code has
loaded and the user option is set. Export the logic from
Hooks.php to the client.
Change-Id: Ica0e58de7ed0d59e3b09645193eb2b691ae41c39
If DiscussionToolsABTest is enabled (set to `all` or a feature), logged
in users who have never used the tool before will be assigned to an a/b
test bucket. If they're in the test bucket, they get the feature
enabled.
If they manually set their beta feature preference, we don't override
that but do maintain their bucket for logging purposes.
Bug: T268191
Change-Id: I9c4d60e9f9aaef11afa7f8661b9c49130dde3ffa
1. Extend the JS modifier to allow adding top-level comments
(that is, replies to headings). PHP modifier doesn't do this
because we'll save the changes using paction=addtopic instead.
2. Subclass CommentController to allow adding a new heading and a
top-level comment underneath it at the same time.
3. A lot of ugly code in ReplyWidget to customize the interface
for this case. Much of it should probably be moved to
CommentController/NewTopicController.
Bug: T267595
Change-Id: I9c707bb7f7aae1b92c72fb4dee436490f8c8409b
Allows for multiple features in the near future.
Separate availability and enabled.
Separate User/Title/Output checks.
Change-Id: I454bd8407675749d93ff3d2b4c5d624b433204db
As a result of 0fc71f60cd, "empty" text
nodes (containing only whitespace) at the end of the comment may be
inside the comment's range, and trying to ignore them caused the
ranges not to match and the frame not to be detected.
Now the code works whether they're inside the comment's range or not.
Add a test case for wrapped discussion comments with HTML comments and
with whitespace.
Bug: T250126
Bug: T268407
Change-Id: I2217ff5a635fd1c9c9e803f46795b1bfb3d17535
Now we don't require the ParserOutput to be available.
As a result, we now check the flag on the latest revision of the page,
rather than the one being viewed.
Change-Id: Id77a332643cb8ad95afc5cec6713fa0a3636a5ce
While working on T270009, I noticed that <style> and <link> nodes
are treated differently, which seemed weird. Rewrite this again,
hopefully this is the last time.
The changed test cases also involve <area> and <input> nodes,
and the new results make more sense to me.
Bug: T264116
Change-Id: I3af90c84768a4b3dc53446927f4dba6f72175a2f
We've recently decided that we want to "extend" comments until
the end of the paragraph (e36dc8e78a,
d0ae6c4e44).
However, we still had this special case that did the opposite: it
ensured that if a comment ended in the middle of a text node, the
comment would not be extended to the end of the node. Remove it.
Note the change in the test file signatures-funny-formattedreply.html,
which actually covered this case specifically.
Change-Id: Id1384bb0c6e1a5f0c70f55efcb4caa240f230f07
The end marker is skipped forward until an open or close
block tag is reached. In tree traversal terms this means
moving either to the next sibling, or the parent (to skip
over close tags).
Bug: T256033
Change-Id: Iaa2c588698790d576ac4f9ecc126f58a082ef6b3
The general rule is that comments start after their preceding
thread item, but when that is a heading we should skip past
the entire <h[1-6]> node to avoid making section edit links
part of the first comment.
Bug: T267988
Change-Id: Ia7f1b27e0a69a9aab7c7da743bf8549479304096
As CommentFormatter no longer needs HTMLFormatter, remove
the inheritance and make addReplyLinks a static method.
Testing locally this is marginally slower, going from 2.55s
to 2.9s for the CommentFormatterTest case.
Bug: T266317
Bug: T267973
Change-Id: If69749cae678a1647a138d782a32032189f55cec
A TreeWalker ends up walking potentially every single subsequent
node in the document looking for a target node. Instead use upwards
traversal to find a common ancestor, then sibling traversal to
compare document order.
This makes calling cloneContents on every comment on a 300k talk page
significantly faster, going from >30s to 500ms locally.
Change-Id: I28a2b8c11d4098d9bc44d19b98e19ccc02273098
Ideally the edit autosummary would be generated in the same
way as in the old wikitext editor: from the wikitext of the
heading. But on the JS side, we don't have access to the
wikitext, or to the PHP method that generates autosummaries.
This might seem crazy at first, but ultimately the point of
the autosummaries is to link to the section heading by its
'id' attribute, so it is perfectly reliable.
Doing it this way depends on $wgFragmentMode being set to
[ 'html5', 'legacy' ] or [ 'html5' ], otherwise the escaped IDs
are super garbled (particularly in non-Latin-alphabet languages)
and can't be unescaped reliably. Conveniently, we already
require that since 9ee0fd69f5.
Bug: T264561
Bug: T266725
Change-Id: I7d35098d672d0edb50d49e22de1686d5cc83b60e
The condition was wrong, it could return either an element child with
.mw-headline, or a non-element child.
Bug: T267284
Change-Id: I28cda22ee8c5fe4a3259621adddd647b31291703
Internal PHP errors (such as "Call to undefined method…") are not Exceptions.
Follow-up to e18a0f3dcd.
Bug: T267035
Change-Id: I3cbf2b6b0d1d8a97cdac9791ec4f7b2ec807c7e5
After recent changes allowing ThreadItems to have IDs, they can now
also have warnings about duplicate IDs.
Bug: T267035
Change-Id: If3edfe34e6e29741e29fac8946a3c88badc4ab7f
The following sniffs are failing and were disabled:
* MediaWiki.Commenting.PropertyDocumentation.MissingDocumentationPrivate
* MediaWiki.Commenting.PropertyDocumentation.MissingDocumentationProtected
* MediaWiki.Commenting.PropertyDocumentation.MissingDocumentationPublic
Additional changes:
* Dropped .inc files from .phpcs.xml (T200956).
Change-Id: I340d6b573e9ae2a99085fb19a705fcf567b03f92
Use the same logic for marking ranges in the document, and ensure
that the heading range does not include section edit links or
section numberings.
Change-Id: I782caafc34fee2a822b0a17b24dd6b9528202eca
If A follows B, then we can assume that B does not follow A.
Calling the function recursively computes that twice,
we can instead make some simple changes to "invert" the result.
Change-Id: I709aca7cb997dd2fe3980468a8c6bde6f366fb5b
It's an expensive method, and we previously called it for
every child of the common ancestor, completely unnecessarily.
These changes follow from two observations:
* If there is a $firstPartiallyContainedChild, then the
first fully contained child must follow it; similarly,
if there is a $lastPartiallyContainedChild, then the
last fully contained child must precede it.
* All nodes between the first and last fully contained
children are also fully contained.
Maybe it can be made cleverer still, but it's a lot better.
Change-Id: I4e596c62274c2c0be115f0ddec42629115b430a4
Skipping them could result in incorrect handling when RESTBase HTML is
outdated.
When a result for a given comment is not found, display an error
instead of assuming it is not transcluded.
Bug: T262065
Change-Id: I14a7a0a25d5181b5c49bd5677f0c002dce5a3cb9
To avoid old threads re-appearing on popular pages when someone
uses a vague title (e.g. dozens of threads titled "question" on
[[Wikipedia:Help desk]]: https://w.wiki/fbN), include the oldest
timestamp in the thread (i.e. date the thread was started) in the
heading ID.
Bug: T264478
Change-Id: If918bfd5e025248923d1939bc86916697ead95a0
Sequential numbers aren't great because they change when an earlier
comment is archived. Parent comment/heading IDs should change less
often.
This also makes much more sense for disambiguating subsections,
e.g. a dozen identical ===Votes=== sections for a dozen proposals.
Bug: T264478
Change-Id: I466454984fd919ebef35f2b37ddb5d86dc842996
Our threads now also contain all replies to their sub-threads.
This is similar to how sections work in MediaWiki, where the parent
section also contains the content of all the lower-level sections.
We're going to need this for notifications about replies in a thread.
Bug: T264478
Change-Id: I241fc58e2088a7555942824b0f184ed21e3a8b6f
Previously, only comments could have IDs, because we only needed IDs
for replying. But we might also use them for notifications soon.
Bug: T264478
Change-Id: I1bcad02bf17ab54bc5028a959543c10f0430836b
The output of CommentFormatter::addReplyLinks() and consequently
ThreadItem::jsonSerialize() can end up in the HTTP cache (Varnish) on
Wikimedia wikis. We need to consider that when changing that code.
Introduce a concept of legacy ID (generated by the older algorithm
after it changes), add some placeholder code that will generate them
in the future, and update some code to find comments by either normal
or legacy IDs.
Add dire comments in a bunch of places (as if that ever helps).
Bug: T264478
Change-Id: I4368f366800ab21b8b184b09378037614fdecd33
"This modifies the original objects…" – I feel like this is obvious
now, but maybe it wasn't so obvious when this code was structured
differently before a2431fe006. Also,
it refers to a variable that doesn't exist.
"FIXME this will clone the reply…" – No, actually, it will not.
It would if replies were associative arrays, but they are objects,
and have always been, ever since the PHP parser was merged in
7b7a2cd69c. Maybe they were arrays
once in Roan's mind before he pushed that for review.
Change-Id: I1348e111699fdbde99cd1f9ef45d8f465f7391b0
We can check whether a node is a child of another node directly,
without iterating over all its children.
Change-Id: I3a26df89365bf765348d96b477c983ec9c4e43fe
* Add the preference
* Only display it when the reply tool is enabled
* Use it when opening the reply tool
* Save it when the menu is toggled from the reply tool interface
Bug: T261539
Change-Id: Icb8fa6b3f1e9a3644669f21b08f34ea8c175f2f9
This is not necessary, and never has been. This variable contains an
object and it's never assigned to.
Instead, the reference creates hard-to-debug bugs (I've just spent
an hour debugging one). When the variable name is reused later in
the same function as the loop variable of another foreach() loop
(such as in If918bfd5e0), the result is overwriting of the last entry
in $this->threadItems with the last entry from the other array.
I was questioning everything I know about variables until I noticed.
Change-Id: Ibb57f915b39dd4d6d2e744903f9ecadd67b1f52d
Also, add tests covering this and the previous bug fixes in this code
(T259818, T261706).
Note that the test data added in tests/cases/ doesn't exactly match
the entire configuration of the wiki, only the parts we want to cover.
This is unlike the data in tests/data/, which was literally copied
from the relevant wikis, and which is used as input for other tests.
Bug: T265500
Change-Id: I29a59a5952f6dc9fb5910434bb6bcc9dcdaa01a9
When a timestamp directly followed a `<div>…</div>` tag (or perhaps
some other wrapper containing lots of content), we would detect the
username from the earliest links in the wrapper (furthest from the
timestamp), rather than the latest links (closest to the timestamp).
Bug: T262573
Change-Id: Id16449a86a731b13dc79846bb30ecf6554e26f1d
The wikitext parser outputs `<p><br></p>` for empty paragraphs, so we
need to ignore `<br>` tags when searching for an "interesting" node
that marks the beginning of a comment. Otherwise the empty paragraphs
mess up the detection of indentation levels.
Bug: T264116
Change-Id: I84a97ab577baa7336b78935ccdc48041ecfc231a
* Export parser data (date format, digits, timezone names, and
messages for weekday/month names) converted to language variants
* Update the parsers to try matching using every variant, in case
the page is displayed in non-default variant (and to avoid
problems with incomplete variant conversion)
Bug: T259818
Change-Id: I04d73992cd31ce06fa79f87df0c0a53d7efc3c58
