Implement add a reference edit check

Change-Id: I4cebc5bbaa34300d1c5bb5fde8277269b14779c9

.eslintignore

@@ -6,6 +6,6 @@
 /docs/
 
 # Language files written automatically by TranslateWiki
-/i18n/**/*.json
-!/i18n/**/en.json
-!/i18n/**/qqq.json
+**/i18n/**/*.json
+!**/i18n/**/en.json
+!**/i18n/**/qqq.json

extension.json

@@ -180,6 +180,10 @@
 			"value": false,
 			"description": "For testing only. Tag edits for the Edit Check project."
 		},
+		"VisualEditorEditCheck": {
+			"value": false,
+			"description": "Enable experimental Edit Check feature."
+		},
 		"VisualEditorUseSingleEditTab": {
 			"value": false
 		}
@@ -218,7 +222,8 @@
 			"i18n/ve-mw",
 			"i18n/ve-mw/api",
 			"i18n/ve-mw/mwlanguagevariant",
-			"i18n/ve-wmf"
+			"i18n/ve-wmf",
+			"modules/editcheck/i18n"
 		]
 	},
 	"ExtensionMessagesFiles": {
@@ -598,10 +603,32 @@
 		"ext.visualEditor.editCheck": {
 			"group": "visualEditorA",
 			"scripts": [
-				"modules/editcheck/init.js"
+				"modules/editcheck/init.js",
+				"modules/editcheck/EditCheckContextItem.js",
+				"modules/editcheck/EditCheckInspector.js"
+			],
+			"styles": [
+				"modules/editcheck/EditCheck.less"
+			],
+			"dependencies": [
+				"ext.visualEditor.core",
+				"ext.visualEditor.mwsave"
+			],
+			"messages": [
+				"editcheck-dialog-action-no",
+				"editcheck-dialog-action-yes",
+				"editcheck-dialog-addref-description",
+				"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-question",
+				"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-description",
+				"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-no-info",
+				"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-already-cited",
+				"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-not-sure",
+				"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-other",
+				"editcheck-dialog-addref-success-notify",
+				"editcheck-dialog-addref-title",
+				"editcheck-dialog-title",
+				"visualeditor-backbutton-tooltip"
 			],
-			"dependencies": [],
-			"messages": [],
 			"targets": [
 				"desktop",
 				"mobile"

includes/Hooks.php

@@ -1113,6 +1113,7 @@ class Hooks implements TextSlotDiffRendererTablePrefixHook {
 			),
 			'useChangeTagging' => $veConfig->get( 'VisualEditorUseChangeTagging' ),
 			'editCheckTagging' => $veConfig->get( 'VisualEditorEditCheckTagging' ),
+			'editCheck' => $veConfig->get( 'VisualEditorEditCheck' ),
 			'namespacesWithSubpages' => $namespacesWithSubpagesEnabled,
 			'specialBooksources' => urldecode( SpecialPage::getTitleFor( 'Booksources' )->getPrefixedURL() ),
 			'rebaserUrl' => $coreConfig->get( 'VisualEditorRebaserURL' ),

modules/editcheck/EditCheck.less

@@ -0,0 +1,35 @@
+/* Toolbar */
+
+.ve-ui-toolbar-group-title {
+	font-weight: bold;
+	flex: 5 !important; /* stylelint-disable-line declaration-no-important */
+	line-height: 3em;
+}
+
+/* Context item */
+
+.ve-ui-editCheckContextItem {
+	> .ve-ui-linearContextItem-head {
+		background: #fce7fe;
+	}
+
+	&-actions {
+		margin-top: 16px;
+	}
+}
+
+/* Selections */
+
+.ve-ce-surface-selections-editCheck .ve-ce-surface-selection {
+	opacity: 0.2;
+}
+
+.ve-ce-surface-selections-editCheck .ve-ce-surface-selection > div {
+	mix-blend-mode: darken;
+	// Adjust target colours to account for 50% opacity
+	background: ( #fce7fe - 0.8 * ( #fff ) ) / 0.2;
+	// border: 1px solid ( ( #d02aac - 0.8 * ( #fff ) ) / 0.2 );
+	border-radius: 2px;
+	padding: 2px;
+	margin: -2px 0 0 -2px;
+}

modules/editcheck/EditCheckContextItem.js

@@ -0,0 +1,126 @@
+/*!
+ * VisualEditor EditCheckContextItem class.
+ *
+ * @copyright 2011-2019 VisualEditor Team and others; see http://ve.mit-license.org
+ */
+
+/**
+ * Context item shown after a rich text paste.
+ *
+ * @class
+ * @extends ve.ui.PersistentContextItem
+ *
+ * @constructor
+ * @param {ve.ui.LinearContext} context Context the item is in
+ * @param {ve.dm.Model} model Model the item is related to
+ * @param {Object} [config]
+ */
+ve.ui.EditCheckContextItem = function VeUiEditCheckContextItem() {
+	// Parent constructor
+	ve.ui.EditCheckContextItem.super.apply( this, arguments );
+
+	// Initialization
+	this.$element.addClass( 've-ui-editCheckContextItem' );
+};
+
+/* Inheritance */
+
+OO.inheritClass( ve.ui.EditCheckContextItem, ve.ui.PersistentContextItem );
+
+/* Static Properties */
+
+ve.ui.EditCheckContextItem.static.name = 'editCheck';
+
+ve.ui.EditCheckContextItem.static.icon = 'quotes';
+
+ve.ui.EditCheckContextItem.static.label = OO.ui.deferMsg( 'editcheck-dialog-addref-title' );
+
+/* Methods */
+
+/**
+ * @inheritdoc
+ */
+ve.ui.EditCheckContextItem.prototype.renderBody = function () {
+	// Prompt panel
+	var acceptButton = new OO.ui.ButtonWidget( {
+		label: ve.msg( 'editcheck-dialog-action-yes' ),
+		icon: 'check'
+	} );
+	var rejectButton = new OO.ui.ButtonWidget( {
+		label: ve.msg( 'editcheck-dialog-action-no' ),
+		icon: 'close'
+	} );
+
+	acceptButton.connect( this, { click: 'onAcceptClick' } );
+	rejectButton.connect( this, { click: 'onRejectClick' } );
+
+	// HACK: Suppress close button on mobile context
+	if ( this.context.isMobile() ) {
+		this.context.closeButton.toggle( false );
+	}
+
+	this.$body.append(
+		$( '<p>' ).text( ve.msg( 'editcheck-dialog-addref-description' ) ),
+		$( '<div>' ).addClass( 've-ui-editCheckContextItem-actions' ).append(
+			acceptButton.$element, rejectButton.$element
+		)
+	);
+};
+
+ve.ui.EditCheckContextItem.prototype.close = function ( data ) {
+	// HACK: Un-suppress close button on mobile context
+	if ( this.context.isMobile() ) {
+		this.context.closeButton.toggle( true );
+	}
+	this.data.saveProcessDeferred.resolve( data );
+};
+
+ve.ui.EditCheckContextItem.prototype.onAcceptClick = function () {
+	var contextItem = this;
+	var fragment = this.data.fragment;
+	var windowAction = ve.ui.actionFactory.create( 'window', this.context.getSurface() );
+	fragment.collapseToEnd().select();
+
+	windowAction.open( 'citoid' ).then( function ( instance ) {
+		return instance.closing;
+	} ).then( function ( data ) {
+		if ( !data ) {
+			// Reference was not inserted - re-open this context
+			setTimeout( function () {
+				// Deactivate again for mobile after teardown has modified selections
+				contextItem.context.getSurface().getView().deactivate();
+				contextItem.context.afterContextChange();
+			}, 500 );
+		} else {
+			// Edit check inspector is already closed by this point, but
+			// we need to end the workflow.
+			contextItem.close( data );
+		}
+	} );
+};
+
+ve.ui.EditCheckContextItem.prototype.onRejectClick = function () {
+	var contextItem = this;
+	var windowAction = ve.ui.actionFactory.create( 'window', this.context.getSurface() );
+	windowAction.open(
+		'editCheckInspector',
+		{
+			fragment: this.data.fragment,
+			saveProcessDeferred: this.data.saveProcessDeferred
+		}
+	).then( function ( instance ) {
+		// contextItem.openingCitoid = false;
+		return instance.closing;
+	} ).then( function ( data ) {
+		if ( !data ) {
+			// Form was closed, re-open this context
+			contextItem.context.afterContextChange();
+		} else {
+			contextItem.close( data );
+		}
+	} );
+};
+
+/* Registration */
+
+ve.ui.contextItemFactory.register( ve.ui.EditCheckContextItem );

modules/editcheck/EditCheckInspector.js

@@ -0,0 +1,151 @@
+/*!
+ * VisualEditor UserInterface EditCheckInspector class.
+ *
+ * @copyright 2011-2020 VisualEditor Team and others; see http://ve.mit-license.org
+ */
+
+/**
+ * Edit check inspector
+ *
+ * @class
+ * @extends ve.ui.FragmentInspector
+ *
+ * @constructor
+ * @param {Object} [config] Configuration options
+ */
+ve.ui.EditCheckInspector = function VeUiEditCheckInspector( config ) {
+	// Parent constructor
+	ve.ui.EditCheckInspector.super.call( this, config );
+
+	// Pre-initialization
+	this.$element.addClass( 've-ui-editCheckInspector' );
+};
+
+/* Inheritance */
+
+OO.inheritClass( ve.ui.EditCheckInspector, ve.ui.FragmentInspector );
+
+ve.ui.EditCheckInspector.static.name = 'editCheckInspector';
+
+// ve.ui.EditCheckInspector.static.title = OO.ui.deferMsg( 'editcheck-dialog-title' );
+ve.ui.EditCheckInspector.static.title = OO.ui.deferMsg( 'editcheck-dialog-addref-title' );
+
+// ve.ui.EditCheckInspector.static.size = 'context';
+
+ve.ui.EditCheckInspector.static.actions = [
+	{
+		label: OO.ui.deferMsg( 'visualeditor-dialog-action-cancel' ),
+		flags: [ 'safe', 'back' ],
+		modes: [ 'mobile', 'desktop' ]
+	},
+	{
+		action: 'continue',
+		icon: 'next',
+		flags: [ 'primary', 'progressive' ],
+		modes: [ 'mobile' ]
+	}
+];
+
+/* Methods */
+
+/**
+ * @inheritdoc
+ */
+ve.ui.EditCheckInspector.prototype.initialize = function () {
+	// Parent method
+	ve.ui.EditCheckInspector.super.prototype.initialize.call( this );
+
+	// Survey panel
+	this.answerRadioSelect = new OO.ui.RadioSelectWidget( {
+		items: [
+			new OO.ui.RadioOptionWidget( {
+				data: 'no-info',
+				label: ve.msg( 'editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-no-info' )
+			} ),
+			new OO.ui.RadioOptionWidget( {
+				data: 'already-cited',
+				label: ve.msg( 'editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-already-cited' )
+			} ),
+			new OO.ui.RadioOptionWidget( {
+				data: 'not-sure',
+				label: ve.msg( 'editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-not-sure' )
+			} ),
+			new OO.ui.RadioOptionWidget( {
+				data: 'other',
+				label: ve.msg( 'editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-other' )
+			} )
+		]
+	} );
+	this.answerRadioSelect.connect( this, { select: 'updateActions' } );
+
+	this.answerConfirm = new OO.ui.ButtonWidget( {
+		flags: [ 'progressive' ],
+		framed: false,
+		label: 'Continue',
+		disabled: true
+	} );
+	this.answerConfirm.toggle( !OO.ui.isMobile() );
+	this.answerConfirm.connect( this, { click: [ 'executeAction', 'continue' ] } );
+
+	this.form.addItems(
+		new OO.ui.FieldsetLayout( {
+			label: ve.msg( 'editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-question' ),
+			items: [
+				new OO.ui.FieldLayout( this.answerRadioSelect, {
+					label: ve.msg( 'editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-description' ),
+					align: 'top'
+				} ),
+				new OO.ui.FieldLayout( this.answerConfirm, {
+					align: 'left'
+				} )
+			]
+		} )
+	);
+};
+
+ve.ui.EditCheckInspector.prototype.updateActions = function () {
+	this.answerConfirm.setDisabled( !this.answerRadioSelect.findSelectedItem() );
+};
+
+/**
+ * @inheritdoc
+ */
+ve.ui.EditCheckInspector.prototype.getSetupProcess = function ( data ) {
+	data = data || {};
+	return ve.ui.EditCheckInspector.super.prototype.getSetupProcess.call( this, data )
+		.first( function () {
+			this.surface = data.surface;
+			this.saveProcessDeferred = data.saveProcessDeferred;
+			this.answerRadioSelect.selectItem( null );
+		}, this );
+};
+
+/**
+ * @inheritdoc
+ */
+ve.ui.EditCheckInspector.prototype.getReadyProcess = function ( data ) {
+	return ve.ui.EditCheckInspector.super.prototype.getReadyProcess.call( this, data )
+		.first( function () {
+			this.actions.setMode( OO.ui.isMobile() ? 'mobile' : 'desktop' );
+		}, this );
+};
+
+ve.ui.EditCheckInspector.prototype.getActionProcess = function ( action ) {
+	if ( action === '' ) {
+		return new OO.ui.Process( function () {
+			this.close();
+		}, this );
+	}
+
+	if ( action === 'continue' ) {
+		return new OO.ui.Process( function () {
+			this.close( { action: 'reject', reason: this.answerRadioSelect.findSelectedItem().getData() } );
+		}, this );
+	}
+
+	return ve.ui.EditCheckInspector.super.prototype.getActionProcess.call( this, action );
+};
+
+/* Registration */
+
+ve.ui.windowFactory.register( ve.ui.EditCheckInspector );

modules/editcheck/i18n/en.json

@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
+{
+	"editcheck-dialog-action-no": "No",
+	"editcheck-dialog-action-yes": "Yes",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-description": "Help readers understand where this information is coming from by adding a citation.",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-question": "Why are you not adding a citation?",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-description": "Other editors would value learning more about your decision to dismiss the citation.",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-no-info": "I didn't add new information",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-already-cited": "My changes are already cited earlier",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-not-sure": "I'm not sure what citation to add",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-other": "Other",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-success-notify": "Thank you for adding a citation!",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-title": "Add a citation",
+	"editcheck-dialog-title": "Before publishing"
+}

modules/editcheck/i18n/fr.json

@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
+{
+	"editcheck-dialog-action-no": "Non",
+	"editcheck-dialog-action-yes": "Oui",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-description": "Aidez les lecteurs à comprendre d'où proviennent ces informations en ajoutant une source.",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-question": "Pourquoi n'ajoutez-vous pas une source ?",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-description": "Les autres éditeurs aimeraient en savoir plus sur votre décision de ne pas ajouter une source.",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-no-info": "Je n'ai pas ajouté de nouvelles informations",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-already-cited": "Mes modifications sont déjà sourcées plus haut",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-not-sure": "Je ne sais pas quelle source ajouter",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-other": "Autre",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-success-notify": "Merci d'avoir ajouté une source !",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-title": "Ajouter une source",
+	"editcheck-dialog-title": "Avant de publier"
+}

modules/editcheck/i18n/qqq.json

@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
+{
+	"editcheck-dialog-action-no": "Label for the no option when asking users if they want to add a citation.",
+	"editcheck-dialog-action-yes": "Label for the no option when asking users if they want to add a citation.",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-description": "Help text explaining why it is helpful to add a citation.",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-question": "Heading for form question asking why the user didn't add a citation.",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-description": "Help text for form question asking why the user didn't add a citation.",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-no-info": "Answer option in repsonse to {{msg-mw|editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-question}}",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-already-cited": "Answer option in repsonse to {{msg-mw|editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-question}}",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-not-sure": "Answer option in repsonse to {{msg-mw|editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-question}}",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-other": "Answer option in repsonse to {{msg-mw|editcheck-dialog-addref-reject-question}}",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-success-notify": "Notification messages shown after a citation is added successfully.",
+	"editcheck-dialog-addref-title": "Title for the edit check context asking user to add a citation.",
+	"editcheck-dialog-title": "Title shown in the toolbar while the user is in the add a citation workflow."
+}

modules/editcheck/init.js

@@ -1,20 +1,20 @@
 mw.editcheck = {};
 
 /**
- * Check if added content in the document model might need a reference
+ * Find added content in the document model that might need a reference
  *
  * @param {ve.dm.DocumentModel} documentModel Document model
  * @param {boolean} [includeReferencedContent] Include content ranges that already
  *  have a reference.
- * @return {boolean}
+ * @return {ve.dm.Selection[]} Content ranges that might need a reference
  */
-mw.editcheck.doesAddedContentNeedReference = function ( documentModel, includeReferencedContent ) {
+mw.editcheck.findAddedContentNeedingReference = function ( documentModel, includeReferencedContent ) {
 	if ( mw.config.get( 'wgNamespaceNumber' ) !== mw.config.get( 'wgNamespaceIds' )[ '' ] ) {
-		return false;
+		return [];
 	}
 
 	if ( !documentModel.completeHistory.getLength() ) {
-		return false;
+		return [];
 	}
 	var operations;
 	try {
@@ -23,7 +23,7 @@ mw.editcheck.doesAddedContentNeedReference = function ( documentModel, includeRe
 		// TransactionSquasher can sometimes throw errors; until T333710 is
 		// fixed just count this as not needing a reference.
 		mw.errorLogger.logError( err, 'error.visualeditor' );
-		return false;
+		return [];
 	}
 
 	var ranges = [];
@@ -45,7 +45,7 @@ mw.editcheck.doesAddedContentNeedReference = function ( documentModel, includeRe
 		// Reached the end of the doc / start of internal list, stop searching
 		return offset < endOffset;
 	} );
-	return ranges.some( function ( range ) {
+	var addedTextRanges = ranges.filter( function ( range ) {
 		var minimumCharacters = 50;
 		// 1. Check that at least minimumCharacters characters have been inserted sequentially
 		if ( range.getLength() >= minimumCharacters ) {
@@ -66,6 +66,10 @@ mw.editcheck.doesAddedContentNeedReference = function ( documentModel, includeRe
 		}
 		return false;
 	} );
+
+	return addedTextRanges.map( function ( range ) {
+		return new ve.dm.LinearSelection( range );
+	} );
 };
 
 /**
@@ -118,3 +122,152 @@ if ( mw.config.get( 'wgVisualEditorConfig' ).editCheckTagging ) {
 		};
 	} );
 }
+
+if ( mw.config.get( 'wgVisualEditorConfig' ).editCheck ) {
+	mw.hook( 've.preSaveProcess' ).add( function ( saveProcess, target ) {
+		var surface = target.getSurface();
+
+		var selections = mw.editcheck.findAddedContentNeedingReference( surface.getModel().getDocument() );
+
+		if ( selections.length ) {
+			var surfaceView = surface.getView();
+			var toolbar = target.getToolbar();
+			var reviewToolbar = new ve.ui.PositionedTargetToolbar( target, target.toolbarConfig );
+			reviewToolbar.setup( [
+				{
+					name: 'back',
+					type: 'bar',
+					include: [ 'editCheckBack' ]
+				},
+				// Placeholder toolbar groups
+				// TODO: Make a proper TitleTool?
+				{
+					name: 'title',
+					type: 'bar',
+					include: []
+				},
+				{
+					name: 'save',
+					// TODO: MobileArticleTarget should ignore 'align'
+					align: OO.ui.isMobile() ? 'before' : 'after',
+					type: 'bar',
+					include: [ 'showSaveDisabled' ]
+				}
+			], surface );
+
+			reviewToolbar.items[ 1 ].$element.removeClass( 'oo-ui-toolGroup-empty' );
+			reviewToolbar.items[ 1 ].$group.append(
+				$( '<span>' ).addClass( 've-ui-editCheck-toolbar-title' ).text( ve.msg( 'editcheck-dialog-title' ) )
+			);
+			if ( OO.ui.isMobile() ) {
+				reviewToolbar.$element.addClass( 've-init-mw-mobileArticleTarget-toolbar' );
+			}
+			target.toolbar.$element.before( reviewToolbar.$element );
+			target.toolbar = reviewToolbar;
+
+			var selection = selections[ 0 ];
+			var highlightNodes = surfaceView.getDocument().selectNodes( selection.getCoveringRange(), 'branches' ).map( function ( spec ) {
+				return spec.node;
+			} );
+
+			surfaceView.drawSelections( 'editCheck', [ ve.ce.Selection.static.newFromModel( selection, surfaceView ) ] );
+			surfaceView.setReviewMode( true, highlightNodes );
+			toolbar.toggle( false );
+			target.onContainerScroll();
+
+			saveProcess.next( function () {
+				var saveProcessDeferred = ve.createDeferred();
+				var fragment = surface.getModel().getFragment( selection, true );
+
+				var context = surface.getContext();
+
+				// Select the found content to correctly the context on desktop
+				fragment.select();
+				// Deactivate to prevent selection suppressing mobile context
+				surface.getView().deactivate();
+
+				context.addPersistentSource( {
+					embeddable: false,
+					data: {
+						fragment: fragment,
+						saveProcessDeferred: saveProcessDeferred
+					},
+					name: 'editCheck'
+				} );
+
+				// Once the context is positioned, clear the selection
+				setTimeout( function () {
+					surface.getModel().setNullSelection();
+				} );
+
+				return saveProcessDeferred.promise().then( function ( data ) {
+					context.removePersistentSource( 'editCheck' );
+
+					surfaceView.drawSelections( 'editCheck', [] );
+					surfaceView.setReviewMode( false );
+
+					reviewToolbar.$element.remove();
+					toolbar.toggle( true );
+					target.toolbar = toolbar;
+					target.onContainerScroll();
+
+					// Check the user inserted a citation
+					if ( data && data.action ) {
+						if ( data.action !== 'reject' ) {
+							mw.notify( ve.msg( 'editcheck-dialog-addref-success-notify' ), { type: 'success' } );
+						}
+						var delay = ve.createDeferred();
+						// If they inserted, wait 2 seconds on desktop before showing save dialog
+						setTimeout( function () {
+							delay.resolve();
+						}, !OO.ui.isMobile() && data.action !== 'reject' ? 2000 : 0 );
+						return delay.promise();
+					} else {
+						return ve.createDeferred().reject().promise();
+					}
+				} );
+			} );
+		}
+	} );
+}
+
+ve.ui.EditCheckBack = function VeUiEditCheckBack() {
+	// Parent constructor
+	ve.ui.EditCheckBack.super.apply( this, arguments );
+
+	this.setDisabled( false );
+};
+OO.inheritClass( ve.ui.EditCheckBack, ve.ui.Tool );
+ve.ui.EditCheckBack.static.name = 'editCheckBack';
+ve.ui.EditCheckBack.static.icon = 'previous';
+ve.ui.EditCheckBack.static.autoAddToCatchall = false;
+ve.ui.EditCheckBack.static.autoAddToGroup = false;
+ve.ui.EditCheckBack.static.title =
+	OO.ui.deferMsg( 'visualeditor-backbutton-tooltip' );
+ve.ui.EditCheckBack.prototype.onSelect = function () {
+	var context = this.toolbar.getSurface().getContext();
+	if ( context.inspector ) {
+		context.inspector.close();
+	} else {
+		context.items[ 0 ].close();
+	}
+	this.setActive( false );
+};
+ve.ui.EditCheckBack.prototype.onUpdateState = function () {
+	this.setDisabled( false );
+};
+ve.ui.toolFactory.register( ve.ui.EditCheckBack );
+
+ve.ui.EditCheckSaveDisabled = function VeUiEditCheckSaveDisabled() {
+	// Parent constructor
+	ve.ui.EditCheckSaveDisabled.super.apply( this, arguments );
+};
+OO.inheritClass( ve.ui.EditCheckSaveDisabled, ve.ui.MWSaveTool );
+ve.ui.EditCheckSaveDisabled.static.name = 'showSaveDisabled';
+ve.ui.EditCheckSaveDisabled.static.autoAddToCatchall = false;
+ve.ui.EditCheckSaveDisabled.static.autoAddToGroup = false;
+ve.ui.EditCheckSaveDisabled.prototype.onUpdateState = function () {
+	this.setDisabled( true );
+};
+
+ve.ui.toolFactory.register( ve.ui.EditCheckSaveDisabled );

modules/ve-mw/init/targets/ve.init.mw.ArticleTarget.js

@@ -1548,11 +1548,11 @@ ve.init.mw.ArticleTarget.prototype.save = function ( doc, options ) {
 	) {
 		var documentModel = this.getSurface().getModel().getDocument();
 		// New content needing a reference
-		if ( mw.editcheck.doesAddedContentNeedReference( documentModel ) ) {
+		if ( mw.editcheck.findAddedContentNeedingReference( documentModel ).length ) {
 			taglist.push( 'editcheck-references' );
 		}
 		// New content, regardless of if it needs a reference
-		if ( mw.editcheck.doesAddedContentNeedReference( documentModel, true ) ) {
+		if ( mw.editcheck.findAddedContentNeedingReference( documentModel, true ).length ) {
 			taglist.push( 'editcheck-newcontent' );
 		}
 	}

modules/ve-mw/preinit/ve.init.mw.ArticleTargetLoader.js

@@ -37,7 +37,7 @@
 		modules.push( 'ext.visualEditor.mwwikitext' );
 	}
 
-	if ( conf.editCheckTagging ) {
+	if ( conf.editCheckTagging || conf.editCheck ) {
 		modules.push( 'ext.visualEditor.editCheck' );
 	}