getPageAsLinkTarget() ); if ( !HookUtils::isAvailableForTitle( $title ) ) { // Not a talk page return; } $user = $newRevRecord->getUser(); if ( !$user ) { // User can be null if the user is deleted, but this is unlikely // to be the case if the user just made an edit return; } $revisionStore = $services->getRevisionStore(); $oldRevRecord = $revisionStore->getPreviousRevision( $newRevRecord, IDBAccessObject::READ_LATEST ); if ( $oldRevRecord !== null ) { $oldItemSet = static::getParsedRevision( $oldRevRecord ); } else { // Page creation $doc = DOMUtils::parseHTML( '' ); $container = DOMCompat::getBody( $doc ); $oldItemSet = $services->getService( 'DiscussionTools.CommentParser' ) ->parse( $container, $title->getTitleValue() ); } $newItemSet = static::getParsedRevision( $newRevRecord ); static::generateEventsFromItemSets( $events, $oldItemSet, $newItemSet, $newRevRecord, $title, $user ); } /** * For each level 2 heading, get a list of comments in the thread grouped by names, then IDs. * (Compare by name first, as ID could be changed by a parent comment being moved/deleted.) * Comments in level 3+ sub-threads are grouped together with the parent thread. * * For any other headings (including level 3+ before the first level 2 heading, level 1, and * section zero placeholder headings), ignore comments in those threads. * * @param ContentThreadItem[] $items * @return ContentCommentItem[][][] */ private static function groupCommentsByThreadAndName( array $items ): array { $comments = []; $threadName = null; foreach ( $items as $item ) { if ( $item instanceof HeadingItem && ( $item->getHeadingLevel() < 2 || $item->isPlaceholderHeading() ) ) { $threadName = null; } elseif ( $item instanceof HeadingItem && $item->getHeadingLevel() === 2 ) { $threadName = $item->getName(); } elseif ( $item instanceof CommentItem && $threadName !== null ) { $comments[ $threadName ][ $item->getName() ][ $item->getId() ] = $item; } } return $comments; } /** * Get a list of all subscribable headings, grouped by name in case there are duplicates. * * @param ContentHeadingItem[] $items * @return ContentHeadingItem[][] */ private static function groupSubscribableHeadings( array $items ): array { $headings = []; foreach ( $items as $item ) { if ( $item->isSubscribable() ) { $headings[ $item->getName() ][ $item->getId() ] = $item; } } return $headings; } /** * Compare two lists of thread items, return those in $new but not $old. * * @param ContentThreadItem[][] $old * @param ContentThreadItem[][] $new * @return iterable */ private static function findAddedItems( array $old, array $new ) { foreach ( $new as $itemName => $nameNewItems ) { // Usually, there will be 0 or 1 $nameNewItems, and 0 $nameOldItems, // and $addedCount will be 0 or 1. // // But when multiple replies are added in one edit, or in multiple edits within the same // minute, there may be more, and the complex logic below tries to make the best guess // as to which items are actually new. See the 'multiple' and 'sametime' test cases. // $nameOldItems = $old[ $itemName ] ?? []; $addedCount = count( $nameNewItems ) - count( $nameOldItems ); if ( $addedCount > 0 ) { // For any name that occurs more times in new than old, report that many new items, // preferring IDs that did not occur in old, then preferring items lower on the page. foreach ( array_reverse( $nameNewItems ) as $itemId => $newItem ) { if ( $addedCount > 0 && !isset( $nameOldItems[ $itemId ] ) ) { yield $newItem; $addedCount--; } } foreach ( array_reverse( $nameNewItems ) as $itemId => $newItem ) { if ( $addedCount > 0 ) { yield $newItem; $addedCount--; } } Assert::postcondition( $addedCount === 0, 'Reported expected number of items' ); } } } /** * Helper for generateEventsForRevision(), separated out for easier testing. */ protected static function generateEventsFromItemSets( array &$events, ContentThreadItemSet $oldItemSet, ContentThreadItemSet $newItemSet, RevisionRecord $newRevRecord, PageIdentity $title, UserIdentity $user ): void { $newComments = static::groupCommentsByThreadAndName( $newItemSet->getThreadItems() ); $oldComments = static::groupCommentsByThreadAndName( $oldItemSet->getThreadItems() ); $addedComments = []; foreach ( $newComments as $threadName => $threadNewComments ) { $threadOldComments = $oldComments[ $threadName ] ?? []; foreach ( static::findAddedItems( $threadOldComments, $threadNewComments ) as $newComment ) { Assert::precondition( $newComment instanceof ContentCommentItem, 'Must be ContentCommentItem' ); $addedComments[] = $newComment; } } $newHeadings = static::groupSubscribableHeadings( $newItemSet->getThreads() ); $oldHeadings = static::groupSubscribableHeadings( $oldItemSet->getThreads() ); $addedHeadings = []; foreach ( static::findAddedItems( $oldHeadings, $newHeadings ) as $newHeading ) { Assert::precondition( $newHeading instanceof ContentHeadingItem, 'Must be ContentHeadingItem' ); $addedHeadings[] = $newHeading; } $removedHeadings = []; // Pass swapped parameters to findAddedItems() to find *removed* items foreach ( static::findAddedItems( $newHeadings, $oldHeadings ) as $oldHeading ) { Assert::precondition( $oldHeading instanceof ContentHeadingItem, 'Must be ContentHeadingItem' ); $removedHeadings[] = $oldHeading; } $mentionedUsers = []; foreach ( $events as &$event ) { if ( $event['type'] === 'mention' || $event['type'] === 'mention-summary' ) { // Save mentioned users in our events, so that we can exclude them from our notification, // to avoid duplicate notifications for a single comment. // Array is keyed by user id so we can do a simple array merge. $mentionedUsers += $event['extra']['mentioned-users']; } if ( count( $addedComments ) === 1 ) { // If this edit was a new user talk message according to Echo, // and we also found exactly one new comment, // add some extra information to the edit-user-talk event. if ( $event['type'] === 'edit-user-talk' ) { $event['extra'] += [ 'comment-id' => $addedComments[0]->getId(), 'comment-name' => $addedComments[0]->getName(), 'content' => $addedComments[0]->getBodyText( true ), ]; } // Similarly for mentions. // We don't handle 'content' in this case, as Echo makes its own snippets. if ( $event['type'] === 'mention' ) { $event['extra'] += [ 'comment-id' => $addedComments[0]->getId(), 'comment-name' => $addedComments[0]->getName(), ]; } } } if ( $addedComments ) { // It's a bit weird to do this here, in the middle of the hook handler for Echo. However: // * Echo calls this from a PageSaveComplete hook handler as a DeferredUpdate, // which is exactly how we would do this otherwise // * It allows us to reuse the generated comment trees without any annoying caching static::addCommentChangeTag( $newRevRecord ); // For very similar reasons, we do logging here static::logAddedComments( $addedComments, $newRevRecord, $title, $user ); } foreach ( $addedComments as $newComment ) { // Ignore comments by other users, e.g. in case of reverts or a discussion being moved. // TODO: But what about someone signing another's comment? if ( $newComment->getAuthor() !== $user->getName() ) { continue; } // Ignore comments which are more than 10 minutes old, as this may be a user archiving // their own comment. (T290803) $revTimestamp = new DateTimeImmutable( $newRevRecord->getTimestamp() ); $threshold = $revTimestamp->sub( new DateInterval( 'PT10M' ) ); if ( $newComment->getTimestamp() <= $threshold ) { continue; } $heading = $newComment->getSubscribableHeading(); if ( !$heading ) { continue; } $events[] = [ // This probably should've been called "dt-new-comment": this code is // unaware if there are any subscriptions to the containing topic and // an event is generated for every comment posted. // However, changing this would require a complex migration. 'type' => 'dt-subscribed-new-comment', 'title' => $title, 'extra' => [ 'subscribed-comment-name' => $heading->getName(), 'comment-id' => $newComment->getId(), 'comment-name' => $newComment->getName(), 'content' => $newComment->getBodyText( true ), 'section-title' => $heading->getLinkableTitle(), 'revid' => $newRevRecord->getId(), 'mentioned-users' => $mentionedUsers, ], 'agent' => $user, ]; $titleForSubscriptions = Title::castFromPageIdentity( $title )->createFragmentTarget( $heading->getText() ); static::addAutoSubscription( $user, $titleForSubscriptions, $heading->getName() ); } foreach ( $removedHeadings as $oldHeading ) { $events[] = [ 'type' => 'dt-removed-topic', 'title' => $title, 'extra' => [ 'subscribed-comment-name' => $oldHeading->getName(), 'heading-id' => $oldHeading->getId(), 'heading-name' => $oldHeading->getName(), 'section-title' => $oldHeading->getLinkableTitle(), 'revid' => $newRevRecord->getId(), ], 'agent' => $user, ]; } $titleObj = Title::castFromPageIdentity( $title ); if ( $titleObj ) { foreach ( $addedHeadings as $newHeading ) { // Don't use $event here as that already exists as a reference from above $addTopicEvent = [ 'type' => 'dt-added-topic', 'title' => $title, 'extra' => [ // As no one can be subscribed to a topic before it has been created, // we will notify users who have subscribed to the whole page. 'subscribed-comment-name' => CommentUtils::getNewTopicsSubscriptionId( $titleObj ), 'heading-id' => $newHeading->getId(), 'heading-name' => $newHeading->getName(), 'section-title' => $newHeading->getLinkableTitle(), 'revid' => $newRevRecord->getId(), ], 'agent' => $user, ]; // Add metadata about the accompanying comment $firstComment = $newHeading->getOldestReply(); if ( $firstComment ) { $addTopicEvent['extra']['comment-id'] = $firstComment->getId(); $addTopicEvent['extra']['comment-name'] = $firstComment->getName(); $addTopicEvent['extra']['content'] = $firstComment->getBodyText( true ); } $events[] = $addTopicEvent; } } } /** * Add our change tag for a revision that adds new comments. */ protected static function addCommentChangeTag( RevisionRecord $newRevRecord ): void { // Unclear if DeferredUpdates::addCallableUpdate() is needed, // but every extension does it that way. DeferredUpdates::addCallableUpdate( static function () use ( $newRevRecord ) { MediaWikiServices::getInstance()->getChangeTagsStore() ->addTags( [ 'discussiontools-added-comment' ], null, $newRevRecord->getId() ); } ); } /** * Add an automatic subscription to the given item, assuming the user has automatic subscriptions * enabled. */ protected static function addAutoSubscription( UserIdentity $user, Title $title, string $itemName ): void { $dtConfig = MediaWikiServices::getInstance()->getConfigFactory()->makeConfig( 'discussiontools' ); if ( $dtConfig->get( 'DiscussionToolsAutoTopicSubEditor' ) === 'any' && HookUtils::shouldAddAutoSubscription( $user, $title ) ) { /** @var SubscriptionStore $parser */ $subscriptionStore = MediaWikiServices::getInstance()->getService( 'DiscussionTools.SubscriptionStore' ); $subscriptionStore->addAutoSubscriptionForUser( $user, $title, $itemName ); } } /** * Return all users subscribed to a comment * * @param Event $event * @param int $batchSize * @return UserIdentity[]|Iterator */ public static function locateSubscribedUsers( Event $event, $batchSize = 500 ) { $commentName = $event->getExtraParam( 'subscribed-comment-name' ); /** @var SubscriptionStore $subscriptionStore */ $subscriptionStore = MediaWikiServices::getInstance()->getService( 'DiscussionTools.SubscriptionStore' ); $subscriptionItems = $subscriptionStore->getSubscriptionItemsForTopic( $commentName, [ SubscriptionStore::STATE_SUBSCRIBED, SubscriptionStore::STATE_AUTOSUBSCRIBED ] ); // Update notified timestamps $subscriptionStore->updateSubscriptionNotifiedTimestamp( null, $commentName ); // TODD: Have this return an Iterator instead? $users = array_map( static function ( SubscriptionItem $item ) { return $item->getUserIdentity(); }, $subscriptionItems ); return $users; } /** * Log stuff to EventLogging's Schema:TalkPageEvent * If you don't have EventLogging installed, does nothing. * * @param array $addedComments * @param RevisionRecord $newRevRecord * @param PageIdentity $title * @param UserIdentity $identity * @return bool Whether events were logged */ protected static function logAddedComments( array $addedComments, RevisionRecord $newRevRecord, PageIdentity $title, UserIdentity $identity ): bool { global $wgDTSchemaEditAttemptStepOversample, $wgDBname; $context = RequestContext::getMain(); $request = $context->getRequest(); // We've reached here through Echo's post-save deferredupdate, which // might either be after an API request from DiscussionTools or a // regular POST from WikiEditor. Both should have this value snuck // into their request if their session is being logged. if ( !$request->getCheck( 'editingStatsId' ) ) { return false; } $editingStatsId = $request->getVal( 'editingStatsId' ); $isDiscussionTools = $request->getCheck( 'dttags' ); $extensionRegistry = ExtensionRegistry::getInstance(); if ( !$extensionRegistry->isLoaded( 'EventLogging' ) ) { return false; } if ( !$extensionRegistry->isLoaded( 'WikimediaEvents' ) ) { return false; } $inSample = static::inEventSample( $editingStatsId ); $shouldOversample = ( $isDiscussionTools && $wgDTSchemaEditAttemptStepOversample ) || ( // @phan-suppress-next-line PhanUndeclaredClassMethod \WikimediaEvents\WikimediaEventsHooks::shouldSchemaEditAttemptStepOversample( $context ) ); if ( !$inSample && !$shouldOversample ) { return false; } $services = MediaWikiServices::getInstance(); $editTracker = $services->getUserEditTracker(); $userIdentityUtils = $services->getUserIdentityUtils(); $commonData = [ '$schema' => '/analytics/mediawiki/talk_page_edit/1.2.0', 'action' => 'publish', 'session_id' => $editingStatsId, 'page_id' => $newRevRecord->getPageId(), 'page_namespace' => $title->getNamespace(), 'revision_id' => $newRevRecord->getId() ?: 0, 'performer' => [ // Note: we're logging the user who made the edit, not the user who's signed on the comment 'user_id' => $identity->getId(), 'user_edit_count' => $editTracker->getUserEditCount( $identity ) ?: 0, // Retention-safe values: 'user_is_anonymous' => !$identity->isRegistered(), 'user_is_temp' => $userIdentityUtils->isTemp( $identity ), 'user_edit_count_bucket' => UserBucketProvider::getUserEditCountBucket( $identity ) ?: 'N/A', ], 'database' => $wgDBname, // This is unreliable, but sufficient for our purposes; we // mostly just want to see the difference between DT and // everything-else: 'integration' => $isDiscussionTools ? 'discussiontools' : 'page', ]; foreach ( $addedComments as $comment ) { $heading = $comment->getSubscribableHeading(); $parent = $comment->getParent(); if ( !$heading || !$parent ) { continue; } if ( $parent->getType() === 'heading' ) { if ( count( $heading->getReplies() ) === 1 ) { // A new heading was added when this comment was created $component_type = 'topic'; } else { $component_type = 'comment'; } } else { $component_type = 'response'; } EventLogging::submit( 'mediawiki.talk_page_edit', array_merge( $commonData, [ 'component_type' => $component_type, 'topic_id' => $heading->getId(), 'comment_id' => $comment->getId(), 'comment_parent_id' => $parent->getId(), ] ) ); } return true; } /** * Should the current session be sampled for EventLogging? * * @param string $sessionId * @return bool Whether to sample the session */ protected static function inEventSample( string $sessionId ): bool { global $wgDTSchemaEditAttemptStepSamplingRate, $wgWMESchemaEditAttemptStepSamplingRate; // Sample 6.25% $samplingRate = 0.0625; if ( isset( $wgDTSchemaEditAttemptStepSamplingRate ) ) { $samplingRate = $wgDTSchemaEditAttemptStepSamplingRate; } if ( isset( $wgWMESchemaEditAttemptStepSamplingRate ) ) { $samplingRate = $wgWMESchemaEditAttemptStepSamplingRate; } if ( $samplingRate === 0 ) { return false; } $inSample = EventLogging::sessionInSample( (int)( 1 / $samplingRate ), $sessionId ); return $inSample; } }