Commit graph

206 commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Bartosz Dziewoński ad04b24ffd Create a hidden revision tag for talk page comments
Bug: T262107
Depends-On: I21159d03eebaf46ad94f4273ba698a59b8019185
Change-Id: Iceddfaf6a4bcc5e8b5c85c8cd5638bf14aa7db03
2021-08-16 15:42:51 +00:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 47510a22f3 EventDispatcher: Fix ignoring level 3+ headings
The code (prior to d25825a754) assumed
that level 3+ headings would always follow a level 2 heading or the
placeholder heading, but we don't generate a placeholder heading if
there are no comments in section zero.

Add more tests to confirm that comments under level 3+ headings (that
are not sub-headings of level 2), and level 1 headings, are ignored
when generating notifications, and do not mess with normal headings.

Bug: T288775
Change-Id: Ic57b56752a4797cb01234f66e0ed7b849752bd70
2021-08-16 15:42:06 +00:00
Bartosz Dziewoński b46893eb7d Remove pointless uses of preserveWhiteSpace property
This DOMDocument property has no effect, because we do not use
DOMDocument methods for parsing HTML, but rather DOMUtils::parseHTML()
provided by Parsoid.

Change-Id: I1d9e73e53f2d44f41cf9dcda4f06ac8647671096
2021-08-09 23:45:48 +02:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 076242e3b4 Revert "Silence JQMIGRATE warnings when running tests"
This reverts commit f075e37303.

No longer needed after Iaf786cd0f1d870cbcf0b968b7adce616c82df3d8
in MediaWiki core, and now causes exceptions because
UNSAFE_restoreLegacyHtmlPrefilter is undefined.

Bug: T280944
Change-Id: I0dbd6fcb5dce939de334815e9fe371425cf5641f
2021-08-06 18:19:42 +00:00
jenkins-bot 10c23d0eb1 Merge "Deal with document body consistently" 2021-08-06 03:08:28 +00:00
jenkins-bot 56f4dbbf86 Merge "Test cases for interactions with events generated by base Echo" 2021-08-03 23:18:46 +00:00
jenkins-bot d14f31fd08 Merge "Improve notifications for comments posted in close succession" 2021-08-03 23:17:55 +00:00
jenkins-bot 352a4d0555 Merge "Test cases for comments posted in close succession" 2021-08-03 20:44:02 +00:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 8de8d80cde Deal with document body consistently
Use `DOMCompat::getBody( ... )` as a nicer getter than
`->getElementsByTagName( 'body' )->item( 0 )`.

Remove overly defensive checks and redundant annotations on its
return value. Since we're dealing with HTML documents throughout,
the document body is guaranteed to exist.

We previously needed some of them to convince Phan when it thought
the body may be null, but this seems to no longer be needed.

Change-Id: If7aee7b6adbfa78269c7ba28b26a6eaa21fe935b
2021-08-03 15:12:55 +02:00
jenkins-bot 1f4706a308 Merge "Recognize links to add a new topic that use Special:NewSection" 2021-08-02 17:42:30 +00:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 80704b6e80 Test cases for interactions with events generated by base Echo
Adding test cases in a separate commit to make it easier to review how
the test results change after I98fbca8e.

* For mentions, the 'mentioned-users' extra parameter is copied to our
  event (which is then used to avoid duplicate notifications).
* For user talk page edit, nothing special happens right now (we use
  the target page title to avoid duplicate notifications, but this is
  not apparent from the test case, since page titles are not present).

Bug: T281590
Bug: T253082
Change-Id: I153e7735f63f1e2643ed881281d807313cd699c3
2021-08-01 12:27:33 +02:00
Bartosz Dziewoński a5099739a6 Improve notifications for comments posted in close succession
In case 4 and case 6, no notifications are expected. In all other
cases we now get the expected notifications.

Bug: T285528
Change-Id: I9e813bb3a053bc1232783f9eae1ad75672b4fa7e
2021-08-01 12:27:33 +02:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 78cb03c471 Test cases for comments posted in close succession
Adding test cases in a separate commit to make it easier to review how
the test results change.

As expected, in every case, no notifications are generated right now.

Bug: T285528
Change-Id: I25308754112c521d2db8c54ef0c82373456d9e31
2021-08-01 12:27:33 +02:00
C. Scott Ananian 25272e7a4a Don't refer directly to PHP dom extension classes; avoid nonstandard behavior
These changes ensure that DiscussionTools is independent of DOM
library choice, and will not break if/when Parsoid switches to an
alternate (more standards-compliant) DOM library.

We run `phan` against the Dodo standards-compliant DOM library,
so this ends up flagging uses of non-standard PHP extensions to
the DOM.  These will be suppressed for now with a "Nonstandard DOM"
comment that can be grepped for, since they will eventually
will need to be rewritten or worked around.

Most frequent issues:

* Node::nodeValue and Node::textContent and Element::getAttribute()
can return null in a spec-compliant implementation.  Add `?? ''` to
make spec-compliant results consistent w/ what PHP returns.

* DOMXPath doesn't accept anything except DOMDocument.  These uses
should be replaced with DOMCompat::querySelectorAll() or similar
(which end up using DOMXPath under the covers for DOMDocument any way,
but are implemented more efficiently in a spec-compliant
implementation).

* A couple of times we have code like:
  `while ($node->firstChild!==null) { $node = $node->firstChild; }`
and phan's analysis isn't strong enough to determine that $node is still
non-null after the while.  This same issue should appear with DOMDocument
but phan doesn't complain for some reason.

One apparently legit issue:

* Node::insertBefore() is once called in a funny way which leans on
the fact that the second option is optional in PHP.  This seems to be
a workaround for an ancient PHP bug, and can probably be safely
removed.

Bug: T287611
Bug: T217867
Change-Id: I3c4f41c3819770f85d68157c9f690d650b7266a3
2021-07-30 18:15:40 -04:00
C. Scott Ananian 5203d30ea6 Use DOMCompat::newDocument() to create a new Document
For compatibility with Parsoid's document abstraction (Parsoid may
switch to an alternate DOM library in the future), don't explicitly
create a new document object using `new DOMDocument`; instead use
the Parsoid wrapper `DOMCompat::newDocument()`.  This ensures that
the Document object created will be compatible with Parsoid.

There are a number of other subtle dependencies on the PHP `dom`
extension in DiscussionTools, like explicit `instanceof` tests; those
will be tweaked in a follow-up patch
(I3c4f41c3819770f85d68157c9f690d650b7266a3) since they do not affect
correctness so long as Parsoid is aliasing Document to a subclass of
the built-in DOMDocument.  Similarly, the Phan warnings we suppress
do not cause runtime errors (because of the fixes included in
c5265341afd9efde6b54ba56dc009aab88eff83c) but phan will be happier
once the follow-up patch lands and aligns all the DOM types.

Bug: T287611
Depends-On: If0671255779571a91d3472a9d90d0f2d69dd1f7d
Change-Id: Ib98bd5b76de7a0d32a29840d1ce04379c72ef486
2021-07-30 18:15:11 -04:00
Bartosz Dziewoński d0e4aeaecb Fix notifications when new comment is under subheading
The user interface only allows you to subscribe to level 2 headings.
But we would generate events for whatever heading was the closest,
If it was e.g. level 3, no one would receive that notification.

Now we generate events for the closest level 2 heading, or we don't
generate the event at all if there isn't one (if the only headings are
of level 3 and below, or level 1, or if the comment is added before
the first heading on the page).

Bug: T286736
Change-Id: Iae99853070e353ab81c9cc29ef1d53c877adfc66
2021-07-24 05:28:10 +02:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 801b57b0f4 Add PHPUnit integration tests for EventDispatcher
Bug: T286608
Change-Id: I711483be80d455f4439e96d37844ee4552619a92
2021-07-24 05:28:04 +02:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 4ebf05d802 Recognize links to add a new topic that use Special:NewSection
Bug: T277371
Change-Id: I40a13d8bf87bcd3ecea1427b444b6b7b621213c4
2021-07-22 22:25:11 +02:00
libraryupgrader b0884b177c build: Updating dependencies
composer:
* mediawiki/mediawiki-codesniffer: 36.0.0 → 37.0.0

npm:
* postcss: 7.0.35 → 7.0.36
  * https://npmjs.com/advisories/1693 (CVE-2021-23368)
* glob-parent: 5.1.1 → 5.1.2
  * https://npmjs.com/advisories/1751 (CVE-2020-28469)
* trim-newlines: 3.0.0 → 3.0.1
  * https://npmjs.com/advisories/1753 (CVE-2021-33623)

Change-Id: I7a71e23da561599da417db3b3077b78d91173bbc
2021-07-22 16:29:04 +00:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 4ebe4b29bb Only show [subscribe] links on sections that contain at least one comment
Bug: T285796
Change-Id: I48264d55464fa6bce56b47fc1075f5d348101676
2021-07-13 02:35:15 +02:00
Bartosz Dziewoński f075e37303 Silence JQMIGRATE warnings when running tests
Disable the legacy htmlPrefilter from jquery.migrate.js, which is
causing noisy warnings when running tests because we use HTML
templates with wacky content in the test module. They look like this:
"JQMIGRATE: HTML tags must be properly nested and closed: <200 KB of HTML>"

Change-Id: Ic9bbd56e24b5769988a52f28d26d8b6d5922b1b4
2021-06-21 21:17:36 +02:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 9c8d709b8a Use placeholder localisation messages in CommentFormatter tests
Otherwise they will fail whenever translations are updated
(and they are failing right now).

Change-Id: I849c57b86d36fb6c7739cc31a74df741e08462f4
2021-06-02 21:46:36 +02:00
Ed Sanders 6a24ceaeca Subscribe/unsubscribe with plain text links
Bug: T279149
Bug: T279151
Change-Id: Ie7d46ea2e8d458fcdad4f91bb89ba038969f6b62
2021-06-01 20:37:47 +02:00
jenkins-bot 90528f2b49 Merge "Fix adding comments in lists containing <dt> tags" 2021-05-25 19:19:49 +00:00
libraryupgrader 12fb65b9f1 build: Updating composer dependencies
* mediawiki/mediawiki-codesniffer: 35.0.0 → 36.0.0
* php-parallel-lint/php-parallel-lint: 1.2.0 → 1.3.0

Change-Id: I5c152292e83e7f3441e2c08b7d0ad23ac90f194b
2021-05-05 11:14:52 +00:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 475aa80057 Fetch user's topic subscriptions on the page in a single query
Previously, we have made a query per each topic on the page.

Bug: T281000
Change-Id: I1029e62a65fc191ca37e1178ea7ffc55afafa1b9
2021-04-28 21:54:26 +00:00
Ed Sanders 1893405635 Code style: Move var declarations inline
Change-Id: I1686603388b050ba4ec22eff23e4806cdf262b87
2021-04-22 17:43:46 +00:00
Bartosz Dziewoński ffd680ee7f Fix adding comments in lists containing <dt> tags
The issue occurred when replying to a comment consisting of multiple
list items, starting with a <dt> (instead of the expected <dd>), so
that the comment is considered to be unindented.

Modifier tried to add the reply directly inside the list (<dl>) rather
than inside the last list item (<dt>), which caused it to be confused
about indentation levels and try to un-indent more times than there
were indentations.

The simplest solution, given the existing code, is to add the reply
outside the list instead, in a new list. This results in a "list gap"
(<dl><dt>...</dt><dd>...</dd></dl><dl><dd>...</dd></dl>), but I think
it's acceptable for this rare case.

There are separate tests cases for old Parser and for Parsoid HTML,
because they parse the original wikitext differently (with the old
Parser producing HTML with a list gap too).

Bug: T279445
Change-Id: Ie0ee960e7090cf051ee547b480c980e9530eda51
2021-04-21 16:00:07 +02:00
Ed Sanders 722a4e5198 Avoid splitting ParserCache on user language
Bug: T280295
Change-Id: I87eab83803d24c11db4d723377bf7b40390b2e70
2021-04-21 11:57:30 +00:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 5103e651be Add tests for CommentFormatter::postprocessTopicSubscription
Change-Id: Ief9648b8805fadcc170c54b627eb669cc8b907b6
2021-04-21 11:57:25 +00:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 4bbfe6cb5d Rename CommentFormatter::addReplyLinks
Bug: T280351
Change-Id: I0d7627d63407e11cca6091f78e4d440eec6efa91
2021-04-21 11:24:03 +00:00
Bartosz Dziewoński a3f665e816 Remove <header> tags around headings for compat with MobileFrontend
We added it because the initial designs for the subscribe action were
much easier to implement like this, and topic "containers" (T269950)
would have required it.

However, the latest design of the subscribe action will not need it
(T279149), and topic containers are still very far away, so let's
remove it for now.

Bug: T280433
Change-Id: I21a23e9bea43f24d265750926fbd62b99038d3f1
2021-04-19 17:47:43 +02:00
Ed Sanders eb7e682d2f Topic subscription front end
Bug: T276996
Change-Id: Ifb62c04c2a0ea8399749b22021d6a1c5a079bf94
2021-04-06 23:28:28 +02:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 42ce942c86 Introduce comment "names" to identify comments across revisions/pages
The existing comment IDs can't be used to find the same comment on
a different revision or page (when it's transcluded), because they
depend on the comment's parent and its position on the page.

Comment names depend only on the author and timestamp. The trade-off
is that they can't distinguish comments posted within the same minute,
or in the same edit, so we will still need the IDs sometimes.

Prefer using comment names when replying, if they're not ambiguous.
This fixes T273413 and T275821.

Heading names depend on the author and timestamp of the oldest comment.
This way we don't have to detect changes to the heading text, but we
can't distinguish headings without any comments.

Bug: T274685
Bug: T273413
Bug: T275821
Change-Id: Id85c50ba38d1e532cec106708c077b908a3fcd49
2021-03-23 16:08:42 +00:00
Ed Sanders c4de603ef9 Give comments IDs so they can be scrolled to with hash links
Bug: T265268
Change-Id: Idb985ed38bdb74e23cb7840899a61dc919f05f6f
2021-03-20 15:43:23 +00:00
Ed Sanders 4a0802065c Make IDs (to be used as URL hashes) wikitext safe
* Use hyphens instead of pipes a separators
* Use underscores for spaces in usernames

Change-Id: I6efd9739fc73e45002e50e64c43ce0de1c2f1239
2021-03-18 20:45:21 +01:00
Bartosz Dziewoński a103abb8ae Ignore warnings about legacy IDs in tests
Change-Id: I3c74b4e65aac9b84494917547cce7eb6a75995b4
2021-03-18 20:42:03 +01:00
Ed Sanders ece8ff69ff Change dt- class prefix to ext-discussiontools-
Longer, but follows the style guide and less likely to conflict.

We need to account for init classes in the cache being around for
a while.

Change-Id: I738bc93393850db320fdbda2b003ca8ac40556da
2021-03-13 14:42:39 +00:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 44f2209abf Trim signatures when added in an empty existing node, too
Add unit tests for appendSignature().

Bug: T276612
Change-Id: Ic44c52f4d54492e092f9396c626380e2637b6f0f
2021-03-08 23:38:46 +00:00
Ed Sanders ccc19d8df2 Add 'href' to reply links for better compatibility with skins
Change-Id: Id948d576bbe5a6d43c4f8a06cdb2cd8ad19be193
2021-03-09 00:04:53 +01:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 5a07139249 CommentFormatterTest: Avoid re-serializing the HTML
The code we're testing already produces a string of serialized HTML,
no need to parse and re-serialize it.

Also, we recently learned that the precise format matters here
(T274709), and now this test *actually* covers the fix for that bug.
Follow-up to 5b26e9664b.

As a downside, this test might now spuriously fail if the format of
the output of Parsoid's XMLSerializer changes. Hopefully that won't
happen too often.

Change-Id: I69b514f545e47dcb437fb39a83edb8e2f19ed99b
2021-03-01 21:30:28 +01:00
jenkins-bot 0eb37a87df Merge "Don't detect comments within quotes" 2021-02-28 22:56:20 +00:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 024a978ffd Don't detect comments within quotes
Bug: T275881
Change-Id: I8f7a4279837bd95ebf5b604ff350c0a3f29c2c05
2021-02-28 22:49:48 +00:00
Bartosz Dziewoński efe95494a8 Improve signature detection to handle formatting on the timestamp
Now it detect signatures generated by en.wp's {{Undated}} template,
and signatures of people who do weird stuff to the timestamps.

Bug: T275938
Change-Id: I27b07f6786ca5433a3c02a5fe68e4716d41401bb
2021-02-27 02:33:30 +01:00
Bartosz Dziewoński af082908a5 Improve merging multiple comments on one paragraph
The horrendous 11-line if() condition did not correctly handle
signatures wrapped in inline formatting markup, like <small>.

Instead, implement this logic in the code for skipping to the end
of a paragraph, which didn't exist yet when that condition was
added, but seems like a much better place to check this now.

Bug: T275934
Change-Id: I5cccff889b5e15b5f8fde0538bf4bccb22e762cf
2021-02-27 02:21:36 +01:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 9fafe72fc7 Broken test cases for comments with double signatures
Bug: T275934
Change-Id: I00edc63b723053e7ac7d26ce5fc1dde4b824380d
2021-02-27 00:12:42 +01:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 5b26e9664b CommentFormatter: Fix inserting placeholder heading marker
This code expected $container->firstChild to be a
<div class="mw-parser-output">, but that element is not present
when we're running on HTML to be saved in parser cache.

We ended up inserting the marker inside whatever node was the
first on the page, and if it was a <style> element, both our
marker and the styles would be lost when serializing, like in
6c7a0ca9a2.

When we're running on final HTML, the marker will now be outside
of <div class="mw-parser-output">, but that seems to be fine. Only
early versions of I4e60fdbc098c1a74757d6e60fec6bcf8e5db37c1 had
problems with that (see comments on patchset 41), but it works now.

The added test case also covers the fix for T274709.

Bug: T275440
Change-Id: I38d45dd8686919be51e1d307ded12b0afe185eb5
2021-02-24 20:32:48 +01:00
jenkins-bot d5b2389ffa Merge "Fix replying outside wrappers for partially indented comments" 2021-02-11 00:09:48 +00:00
jenkins-bot 89dd44bb35 Merge "More test cases for comment wrappers (multiple siblings)" 2021-02-09 18:07:14 +00:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 9d2b35828d Fix replying outside wrappers for partially indented comments
Top-level comments that start or end with a list (inconsistent
indentation) would not have triggered the logic for detecting
wrappers.

Bug: T273692
Change-Id: Idcb4eed73e391f5f86eca2eb05cb3cea0d86f30a
2021-02-08 22:18:37 +01:00