Many methods are covered indirectly, and using method-level
@covers filters means these are reported as not being covered.
Change-Id: I94eb3e8c48209ff0b6bfc09e18c93555bb167e8f
The implementation in Parser doesn't descend into sub-thread.
Re-use the getThreadSummary method in ThreadItem and traverse
the thread properly.
Bug: T298617
Change-Id: I318d9012eb83f37ccbe463923524ef2e9f995ced
This changes a vast number of test expected-outputs because it affects
the order of the keys when serialized.
Bug: T315400
Change-Id: I6ad2cded6ba7cb2cc5e5ba37ea60f4b18ecc26be
In the future the notifications can be improved to look up
the new location of the comment, using the permalinks data.
Depends-On: Ia8a21749a8edc20f34b2a3e445278ea6922b9109
Bug: T299657
Change-Id: I5f5e7b73fb84ff0d31fb8260b24066a17da71628
We can no longer change IDs so easily, because they're stored in the
permalink database, so remove this mechanism to make sure it's not
accidentally used in the future.
Change-Id: I392ee1f49c48fc2f23d05e9a37c643438b4f2b9a
We didn't correctly reconcile the changes from
Ie0412b9f238d5ff8e54fd2ea358c1c26e303f4e1 and
I419883b5f9a4291b4bf575d57195d553fd5e291e.
Bug: T315821
Change-Id: I5a93cbb3bf029b352e808cbd9cb1ea3286e20c94
Move the code that generates these wrapper nodes and attributes
from postprocessReplyTool() (only called when reply tool is enabled)
to addDiscussionToolsInternal (always called).
This undoes some changes from 31c57d594a and 980b2c38bc.
Bug: T314707
Change-Id: I07ed210375d494047670015410430c087d67f21a
Rather than setting it on both the reply link and the reply button,
set it on their parent element.
Update ReplyLinksController to handle this.
Change-Id: I650e9c0ebd354a82b8f66a63c5b4c02b2e29b105
This improves the behavior when replying to these comments
and the message snippets shown in notifications.
Bug: T313097
Change-Id: Ia10400472c9e999fa526c7437a03b72461c37b74
Othercontent would often contain the opening tag of the next heading /
section. By looking for the closest node with a previousSibling we can
more-reliably escape the heading.
Also, only add the initial placeholder if there's content before the
first heading. We do this by testing for any siblings before the
startContainer of the first heading -- if there are any, assume this
means there's some sort of content. (This can still result in a
placeholder with `othercontent:""` if there's only whitespace before
the first heading.)
Bug: T313850
Change-Id: I080205b74413c46d3cf3442e79276145aaa9439c
* clock, userAvatar, speechBubble were dropped before topic
containers was merged
* Load ellipsis & edit icons on mobile only
* Load bell & bellOutline for topic subscriptions button
Change-Id: I77d1336627b564be756e3ec50b4686b8f9ac72dc
Rename ThreadItem to ContentThreadItem, then create a new ThreadItem
interface containing only the methods that we'll be able to implement
using only the persistently stored data (no parsing), then create a
DatabaseThreadItem. Do the same for CommentItem and HeadingItem.
ThreadItemSet gets a similar treatment, but it's basically only for
Phan's type checking. (This is sad.)
Change-Id: I1633049befe8ec169753b82eb876459af1f63fe8
name and id are supposed to never be null. Calling getName() or
getId() on this object would cause an exception.
Change-Id: I5f95b7d9e4ce4550b550ee758fc86f032b676731
For comments posted on or after 2022-07-12 (configurable), use a
shorter format, identical to the timestamps MediaWiki uses in URLs.
Changing the format for already existing comments would involve
difficult migrations, therefore we elect not to do it.
Bug: T304595
Change-Id: I387051a6a3a1d84cfae45c3e1516db870cc8b977
Change the HeadingItem constructor to take a 'null' headingLevel
and store this internally with the constant. Change the JSON
serializer to convert this back to null.
Change-Id: I27508eed75d94b99c5189548919309f8da7deb75
While in many cases the class will never be sub-classed, it's easier
just to always use static:: and not worry about predicting which
classes might have problems in the future.
Change-Id: I23072a1701b5acf62bb3379a877de97627d8fcf3
We previously ignored them before timezone indicator (e9c401e3aa),
but they can end up in other places too, e.g. after the time.
Now we ignore them after every token. This is way overkill, but it
shouldn't hurt.
Bug: T308448
Change-Id: I20f7aaa34dba23f2a2faf1be258c1aea32ab770f
Change the order of checks to ensure that we have at least one comment
before we try comparing ranges, to avoid issues with empty headings
having collapsed ranges. It should be a tiny bit faster this way, too.
Bug: T304377
Change-Id: I59ad30cfc075dcec882e048d2d199744efec2114
We were calling Title::newFromText() before setupEnv(), which meant
that the title for each test case was parsed using the default rules
for English, rather than the rules for the specified wiki.
This only makes a practical difference for tests with self-links.
Changed the only such test to demonstrate the fix.
Change-Id: I45561f1c9f0d149e2b743f0000b742bf6fc014af
Also fix a bug where headings would be ignored while checking for
comment frames. See task for detailed explanation.
Bug: T303396
Change-Id: I6495826b4b050ea80680e0798ac6ab4497a7c09e
Since times immemorial, and for reasons lost to history, our test code
was adding an extra <div> wrapper before parsing the HTML used for
tests. This wasn't a problem, until now, because I want to add some
tests for T303396 that need to check that the *real* wrappers present
in some test cases are handled correctly.
Changes to test cases mostly remove a leading "0/" from serialized
ranges, corresponding to removing the extra wrapper.
Change-Id: Ia50e3590538c8cd274b02d2a937ba1a3fbb4ac89
It is friendlier for static analysis tools like Phan, which can't
infer anything from the `->nodeType === …` checks, and we were already
using it in most places.
Fix newly revealed Phan failures (and one unneeded suppression).
Change-Id: Id789f05e16a210f7ba22ca7514587c392fac0741
Also special-case thumbnail wrappers generated by
MediaTransformOutput::linkWrap, for compatibility with
TimedMediaHandler.
Bug: T301427
Bug: T302296
Change-Id: I7f48d8b2261507c5a33526c54109f5187d062ed3
Previously, we required a signature at the end of the comment.
This was a pretty rough heuristic that did not correctly handle
many comments that we would consider entirely properly signed
in CommentParser (e.g. comments wrapped in formatting like
<small>…</small>, comments with a post-scriptum or in parentheses,
or comments generated by various templates).
Now we process the user input using the same code that adds reply
links, and only add a signature when we detect that there really
isn't a signature (including template-generated), or if the signature
is in the wrong place and would result in the reply link showing up
in the wrong place as well (not at the end of the comment).
Bug: T278442
Bug: T268558
Bug: T278355
Bug: T291421
Bug: T282983
Change-Id: I46b6110af328ebdf93b7dfc2bd941e04391a1599
We were rendering the preview in a completely different way from how
we would add the real reply, and the results would be different
sometimes, particularly for multi-line comments with messed-up markup.
Render it server-side instead, in a very similar way to real replies
(generating a DOM list node and transforming it through Parsoid),
although without the whole context of the page to improve performance.
We can remove a lot of client-side code that was used solely for this.
This will allow the preview to accurately display the signatures when
we change how they are added (T278442), without us having to implement
those changes again from scratch for the preview.
Change-Id: I53341f4d4075c25b67ec3b3032bff9b8a880dcd3
Goal:
-----
Finishing the work from Iadb7757debe000025e52770ca51ebcf24ca8ee66
by changing CommentParser::parse() to return a data object, instead of
the whole parser.
Changes:
--------
ThreadItemSet.php:
ThreadItemSet.js:
* New data class to access the results of parsing a discussion. Most
methods and properties are moved from CommentParser with no changes.
CommentParser.php:
Parser.js:
* parse() returns a new ThreadItemSet.
* Remove methods moved to ThreadItemSet.
* Placeholder headings are generated slightly differently, as we process
things in a different order.
* Grouping threads and computing IDs/names is no longer lazy. We always
needed IDs/names anyway.
* computeId() explicitly uses a ThreadItemSet to check the existing IDs
when de-duplicating.
controller.js:
* Move the code for turning some nodes annotated by CommentFormatter
into a ThreadItemSet (previously a Parser) from controller#init to
ThreadItemSet.static.newFromAnnotatedNodes, and rewrite it to handle
assigning parents/replies and recalculating legacy IDs more nicely.
* mw.dt.pageThreads is now a ThreadItemSet.
Change-Id: I49bfe019aa460651447fd383f73eafa9d7180a92
Goal:
-----
To have a method like CommentParser::parse(), which just takes a node
to parse and a title and returns plain data, so that we don't need to
keep track of the config to construct a CommentParser object (the
required config like content language is provided by services) and
we don't need to keep that object around after parsing.
Changes:
--------
CommentParser.php:
* …is now a service. Constructor only takes services as arguments.
The node and title are passed to a new parse() method.
* parse() should return plain data, but I split this part to a separate
patch for ease of review: I49bfe019aa460651447fd383f73eafa9d7180a92.
* CommentParser still cheats and accesses global state in a few places,
e.g. calling Title::makeTitleSafe or CommentUtils::getTitleFromUrl,
so we can't turn its tests into true unit tests. This work is left
for future commits.
LanguageData.php:
* …is now a service, instead of a static class.
Parser.js:
* …is not a real service, but it's changed to behave in a similar way.
Constructor takes only the required config as argument,
and node and title are instead passed to a new parse() method.
CommentParserTest.php:
parser.test.js:
* Can be simplified, now that we don't need a useless node and title
to test internal methods that don't use them.
testUtils.js:
* Can be simplified, now that we don't need to override internal
ResourceLoader stuff just to change the parser config.
Change-Id: Iadb7757debe000025e52770ca51ebcf24ca8ee66
The Data class contained utilities for two unrelated purposes.
Split each half to a separate class.
Notably, this improves the signature of the getLocalData() function.
Change-Id: Icde615fb9d483fee1f352c34909b37f8ffde8081
(suggested by PhpStorm)
composer.json:
* Document required PHP extensions
Parser.js:
* Remove incorrect param documentation
* Fix some typos in comments (missing parentheses)
CommentParser.php:
* Fix some typos in comments (missing parentheses)
ImmutableRange.php:
* Remove unused property
* Add a `throw` to indicate that code path is unreachable
SubscribedNewCommentPresentationModel.php:
* Add missing `return false`
CommentParserTest.php:
* Remove unnecessary pass-by-reference
CommentModifierTest.php:
* Remove unused variable
CommentParserTest.php:
* Don't construct Element objects directly. PHP's DOMElement allows
it, but Parsoid/Dodo's doesn't, and we use the latter for static
analysis. This generates all kinds of confusing warnings.
Change-Id: Ia9598ebea0e99830dd485296e94a9d96acc4b258
It adds white-space between block tags and strips invisible tags.
It may be slightly slower (it takes HTML as input rather than DOM, so
we need to serialize the HTML first and then call it, rather than only
find and concatenate text nodes), but the difference is negligible,
and it seems better to use this method than to try to re-implement it.
Test runtime went from ~9.0s to ~9.5s locally, when testing using:
php tests/phpunit/phpunit.php \
extensions/DiscussionTools/tests/phpunit/ThreadItemTest.php \
--filter getText
Bug: T219138
Change-Id: I0cb89ebd2160e1ef499b78573c6688f493a4c42f
Goal: To be able to re-use or test the transformations we previously
performed in addWikitextReply() / addHtmlReply(), without requiring
a Comment object or adding the result as a reply.
Change-Id: I040c4be9b6b9bddba661f30fd0566f8850673074
* We don't need it anywhere in JS, since we're not sending that HTML
to Parsoid.
* We only need it on the nodes directly containing our reply lines in
PHP, not all over the place.
Change-Id: I0a04388225f32654dda2f599442cd27a303b5d0a
When we encounter a node that doesn't represent comment contents, e.g.:
* a [reply] link we inserted (T297034#7641334)
* an {{outdent}} template (see changed test case)
…we should ignore it together with its descendants (like in
Parser#nextInterestingLeafNode), instead of processing descendants
and possibly detecting comment contents in them.
Follow-up to 8de940b587,
72b9c2c6f5.
Bug: T297034
Change-Id: Ib2fa40c5fa389572b0e88ef558728fa06e3621b0
Prior to 8de940b5, the comments on this page would not be marked as
partially transcluded.
Bug: T298408
Change-Id: Ib7eb8b4113151048c0e778b3530600d98dd8f705
These are not used for anything yet, but soon the parser will
want to know the title of the page it is parsing.
Change-Id: I02fa5d63fae78f3e92032d93bc27ac5c744faecb
The following values for configuration variables are supported:
$wgDiscussionToolsReplyIndentation = 'invisible'; (default)
$wgDiscussionToolsReplyIndentation = 'bullet';
Bug: T259864
Change-Id: Icefad79630adc6ed35687498614e6a03ede1451b
Reimplement getFullyCoveredSiblings() using compareRanges(), which
checks basically the same thing, but works better and I like it more.
Bug: T297034
Change-Id: I33dc1d088bdee984064315290e378bfbfa830b10
Previously: 569db3603c (2020-06).
Unfortunately we've found cases where the previous implementation
doesn't work correctly, resulting in comments being added to the wrong
pages or page corruption.
Bug: T289873
Bug: T298051
Change-Id: Id867b3005ebc46906d6df852a525fcaec9e6b19b
Comment boundaries are stored as a DOM parent node plus a child index.
Because of that, inserting anything into the DOM before a comment –
such as another comment's start/end markers – would cause us to insert
subsequent comments' markers into the wrong places.
This issue didn't affect many pages, because usually any parent node
would have just one comment in it. Only pages with comment boundaries
outside of any wrappers (directly inside the root node) were broken.
Just process the list in reverse to fix this.
Bug: T298096
Change-Id: Iccffc36b71e9fcf3d72c4db2b9459d39042f7a2d
Servers as another test case for partially transcluded comments,
and a test case for comment start markers placed outside of
paragraphs.
Bug: T298051
Bug: T298096
Change-Id: Id07d2f57708c037578cb653c83848490c9a15fc6
We're probably not going to use it again, and I don't want to make the
effort of rewriting it in Id867b3005ebc46906d6df852a525fcaec9e6b19b.
Change-Id: I0b02533f7c9b8c1b0df271e03a74063f123d0dff
Data used for the tests assumes there are no variants for English,
and some tests fail when there are. Correct behavior with language
variants is tested using other languages.
Change-Id: I348a0ba0389c2a18644ce5e05c7f37d8f26a8c55
Usually this isn't a problem, because the comments are marked as
template-generated and we don't allow replying to them. But we had a
special case where we were trying to skip over some invisible
elements, which was causing us to skip into the middle of the
about-group in some cases. When Parsoid sees that, it serializes the
contents twice.
Bug: T290940
Change-Id: I9fe0b8d43ab874ccef371990799f77bfc46bc954
We do something similar in CommentItem.js with a moment object.
The object can be converted to a string when required.
Change-Id: Id7221e9201db0d89c3b771574634c878c9515ca0
These types can be passed a parameters to any file without
creating a dependency, so it makes more sense to allow
the globally.
Change-Id: I5504465fd997b46547642e7046993b370b85586e
The PHP DOM extension measures lengths and offsets in Unicode codepoints.
Our PHP code used UTF-8 bytes, causing some offsets to be slightly off.
Now it mostly uses Unicode codepoints as well (we're forced to use bytes
in a few places, because preg_match returns offsets in bytes).
In practice, this had no visible effect to the user. It caused the
markers `<span data-mw-comment-end="..."></span>` to be placed at
the end of their container instead of the correct position when the
timestamp contained multibyte characters (e.g. "ź" in Polish); but
the correct position is usually at the end of the container anyway.
In the test cases, the only difference is placing these markers before
a trailing line break inside `<p>...</p>` tags rather than before it.
The patch also accidentally fixes another bug, where element nodes
with no children (mostly <img>) were incorrectly excluded when calling
cloneContents(), because they were treated as if they were text nodes.
Change-Id: Iccdccf1078598f4b62cab96225e9c85a4c0e93ee
If the user talk edit or mention coincides with exactly one new comment:
* Change the primary link to be a direct link to the comment
* Add a text snippet to notifications that don't already include one
(user talk edits that are not new sections).
This is done for all such notifications, regardless of whether anyone
has topic subscriptions enabled.
Bug: T281590
Bug: T253082
Change-Id: I98fbca8e57845cd7c82ad533c393db953e4e5643
* ThreadItem::getText
* CommentItem::getBodyText (used when generating notifications)
* ThreadItem::getHTML (may soon be used in API)
* CommentItem::getBodyHTML (may soon be used in API)
* ImmutableRange::cloneContents (the common implementation for all
of the above)
The outputs are only lightly reviewed. This is mostly meant to
document the current behavior rather than the expected behavior,
to avoid making unintentional changes while refactoring.
Change-Id: I14471ee4969aa3d0b5577d9de2a6d4462fab4d09
The code (prior to d25825a754) assumed
that level 3+ headings would always follow a level 2 heading or the
placeholder heading, but we don't generate a placeholder heading if
there are no comments in section zero.
Add more tests to confirm that comments under level 3+ headings (that
are not sub-headings of level 2), and level 1 headings, are ignored
when generating notifications, and do not mess with normal headings.
Bug: T288775
Change-Id: Ic57b56752a4797cb01234f66e0ed7b849752bd70
This DOMDocument property has no effect, because we do not use
DOMDocument methods for parsing HTML, but rather DOMUtils::parseHTML()
provided by Parsoid.
Change-Id: I1d9e73e53f2d44f41cf9dcda4f06ac8647671096
This reverts commit f075e37303.
No longer needed after Iaf786cd0f1d870cbcf0b968b7adce616c82df3d8
in MediaWiki core, and now causes exceptions because
UNSAFE_restoreLegacyHtmlPrefilter is undefined.
Bug: T280944
Change-Id: I0dbd6fcb5dce939de334815e9fe371425cf5641f
Use `DOMCompat::getBody( ... )` as a nicer getter than
`->getElementsByTagName( 'body' )->item( 0 )`.
Remove overly defensive checks and redundant annotations on its
return value. Since we're dealing with HTML documents throughout,
the document body is guaranteed to exist.
We previously needed some of them to convince Phan when it thought
the body may be null, but this seems to no longer be needed.
Change-Id: If7aee7b6adbfa78269c7ba28b26a6eaa21fe935b
Adding test cases in a separate commit to make it easier to review how
the test results change after I98fbca8e.
* For mentions, the 'mentioned-users' extra parameter is copied to our
event (which is then used to avoid duplicate notifications).
* For user talk page edit, nothing special happens right now (we use
the target page title to avoid duplicate notifications, but this is
not apparent from the test case, since page titles are not present).
Bug: T281590
Bug: T253082
Change-Id: I153e7735f63f1e2643ed881281d807313cd699c3
In case 4 and case 6, no notifications are expected. In all other
cases we now get the expected notifications.
Bug: T285528
Change-Id: I9e813bb3a053bc1232783f9eae1ad75672b4fa7e
Adding test cases in a separate commit to make it easier to review how
the test results change.
As expected, in every case, no notifications are generated right now.
Bug: T285528
Change-Id: I25308754112c521d2db8c54ef0c82373456d9e31
These changes ensure that DiscussionTools is independent of DOM
library choice, and will not break if/when Parsoid switches to an
alternate (more standards-compliant) DOM library.
We run `phan` against the Dodo standards-compliant DOM library,
so this ends up flagging uses of non-standard PHP extensions to
the DOM. These will be suppressed for now with a "Nonstandard DOM"
comment that can be grepped for, since they will eventually
will need to be rewritten or worked around.
Most frequent issues:
* Node::nodeValue and Node::textContent and Element::getAttribute()
can return null in a spec-compliant implementation. Add `?? ''` to
make spec-compliant results consistent w/ what PHP returns.
* DOMXPath doesn't accept anything except DOMDocument. These uses
should be replaced with DOMCompat::querySelectorAll() or similar
(which end up using DOMXPath under the covers for DOMDocument any way,
but are implemented more efficiently in a spec-compliant
implementation).
* A couple of times we have code like:
`while ($node->firstChild!==null) { $node = $node->firstChild; }`
and phan's analysis isn't strong enough to determine that $node is still
non-null after the while. This same issue should appear with DOMDocument
but phan doesn't complain for some reason.
One apparently legit issue:
* Node::insertBefore() is once called in a funny way which leans on
the fact that the second option is optional in PHP. This seems to be
a workaround for an ancient PHP bug, and can probably be safely
removed.
Bug: T287611
Bug: T217867
Change-Id: I3c4f41c3819770f85d68157c9f690d650b7266a3
