diff --git a/i18n/en.json b/i18n/en.json
index b3474e00e..2e20402a0 100644
--- a/i18n/en.json
+++ b/i18n/en.json
@@ -137,6 +137,9 @@
 	"discussiontools-topicsubscription-notify-unsubscribed-body": "You will no longer receive notifications about new comments in this topic.",
 	"discussiontools-topicsubscription-notify-unsubscribed-title": "You have unsubscribed.",
 	"discussiontools-topicsubscription-pager-actions": "Actions",
+	"discussiontools-topicsubscription-pager-created": "First subscribed",
+	"discussiontools-topicsubscription-pager-notified": "Latest notification",
+	"discussiontools-topicsubscription-pager-notified-never": "never",
 	"discussiontools-topicsubscription-pager-page": "Page",
 	"discussiontools-topicsubscription-pager-topic": "Topic",
 	"discussiontools-topicsubscription-pager-unsubscribe-button": "Unsubscribe",
diff --git a/i18n/qqq.json b/i18n/qqq.json
index c94b8aa55..e62a275a8 100644
--- a/i18n/qqq.json
+++ b/i18n/qqq.json
@@ -149,6 +149,9 @@
 	"discussiontools-topicsubscription-notify-unsubscribed-body": "Body of notification shown when a user unsubscribes from a topic.",
 	"discussiontools-topicsubscription-notify-unsubscribed-title": "Title of notification shown when a user unsubscribes from a topic.",
 	"discussiontools-topicsubscription-pager-actions": "Used on [[mw:Special:TopicSubscriptions|Special:TopicSubscriptions]] as a table heading.\n{{identical|Action}}",
+	"discussiontools-topicsubscription-pager-created": "Used on [[mw:Special:TopicSubscriptions|Special:TopicSubscriptions]] as a table heading.",
+	"discussiontools-topicsubscription-pager-notified": "Used on [[mw:Special:TopicSubscriptions|Special:TopicSubscriptions]] as a table heading.",
+	"discussiontools-topicsubscription-pager-notified-never": "Used on [[mw:Special:TopicSubscriptions|Special:TopicSubscriptions]] in the table.",
 	"discussiontools-topicsubscription-pager-page": "Used on [[mw:Special:TopicSubscriptions|Special:TopicSubscriptions]] as a table heading.",
 	"discussiontools-topicsubscription-pager-topic": "Used on [[mw:Special:TopicSubscriptions|Special:TopicSubscriptions]] as a table heading.",
 	"discussiontools-topicsubscription-pager-unsubscribe-button": "Used on [[mw:Special:TopicSubscriptions|Special:TopicSubscriptions]] in the table, as a button label.",
diff --git a/includes/TopicSubscriptionsPager.php b/includes/TopicSubscriptionsPager.php
index 0e90acc13..4bf1c5c12 100644
--- a/includes/TopicSubscriptionsPager.php
+++ b/includes/TopicSubscriptionsPager.php
@@ -18,7 +18,10 @@ class TopicSubscriptionsPager extends TablePager {
 	 * won't get "stuck" when e.g. 50 subscriptions are all created within a second.
 	 */
 	private const INDEX_FIELDS = [
+		// The auto-increment ID will almost always have the same order as sub_created
+		// and the field already has an index.
 		'_topic' => [ 'sub_id' ],
+		'sub_created' => [ 'sub_id' ],
 		// TODO Add indexes that cover these fields to enable sorting by them
 		// 'sub_state' => [ 'sub_state', 'sub_item' ],
 		// 'sub_created' => [ 'sub_created', 'sub_item' ],
@@ -60,6 +63,8 @@ class TopicSubscriptionsPager extends TablePager {
 		return [
 			'_topic' => $this->msg( 'discussiontools-topicsubscription-pager-topic' )->text(),
 			'_page' => $this->msg( 'discussiontools-topicsubscription-pager-page' )->text(),
+			'sub_created' => $this->msg( 'discussiontools-topicsubscription-pager-created' )->text(),
+			'sub_notified' => $this->msg( 'discussiontools-topicsubscription-pager-notified' )->text(),
 			'_unsubscribe' => $this->msg( 'discussiontools-topicsubscription-pager-actions' )->text(),
 		];
 	}
@@ -81,6 +86,14 @@ class TopicSubscriptionsPager extends TablePager {
 				$title = Title::makeTitleSafe( $row->sub_namespace, $row->sub_title );
 				return $linkRenderer->makeLink( $title, $title->getPrefixedText() );
 
+			case 'sub_created':
+				return htmlspecialchars( $this->getLanguage()->userTimeAndDate( $value, $this->getUser() ) );
+
+			case 'sub_notified':
+				return $value ?
+					htmlspecialchars( $this->getLanguage()->userTimeAndDate( $value, $this->getUser() ) ) :
+					$this->msg( 'discussiontools-topicsubscription-pager-notified-never' )->escaped();
+
 			case '_unsubscribe':
 				$title = Title::makeTitleSafe( $row->sub_namespace, $row->sub_title );
 				return (string)new OOUI\ButtonWidget( [
@@ -123,6 +136,8 @@ class TopicSubscriptionsPager extends TablePager {
 				'sub_namespace',
 				'sub_title',
 				'sub_section',
+				'sub_created',
+				'sub_notified',
 			],
 			'conds' => [
 				'sub_user' => $this->getUser()->getId(),
@@ -135,7 +150,7 @@ class TopicSubscriptionsPager extends TablePager {
 	 * @inheritDoc
 	 */
 	public function getDefaultSort() {
-		return '_topic';
+		return 'sub_created';
 	}
 
 	/**
@@ -149,7 +164,7 @@ class TopicSubscriptionsPager extends TablePager {
 	 * @inheritDoc
 	 */
 	protected function isFieldSortable( $field ) {
-		// Topic is set to the auto-ID field (sub_id), so sorting by it is not very useful
+		// Hide the sort button for "Topic" as it is more accurately shown as "Created"
 		return isset( static::INDEX_FIELDS[$field] ) && $field !== '_topic';
 	}
 }