Commit graph

73 commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Subramanya Sastry fc0a239887 Document Parsoid's differing HTML for follows
* Add a file-level comment in the cite tests file.
* Document the CSS rule that hides the Parsoid HTML.

Change-Id: I27dc6d5f6ab09b67e28ce88a2e13bf2d1a13e9c0
2023-03-13 14:38:30 -05:00
Subramanya Sastry d8da2cbb28 Enable integrated testing with Parsoid
* The failing tests added to known failures are the tests
  known to fail as documented in T307741.

Bug: T307741
Change-Id: I5e5163a4bd093768d1364516ed79fb2d225ee656
2023-03-07 00:22:55 -06:00
thiemowmde c207e343a2 Add test case with conflicting dir="…" values
Just to document the current behavior.

Bug: T202593
Change-Id: I87c4118cd8ca9f860319dc1d3a25f448019339c4
2023-03-01 08:54:56 -06:00
thiemowmde 899775b5ce Remove problematic spaces from a parser test case + Rename a test file
IDEs like my PHPStorm trim spaces from the end of the line. It looks
like they are not relevant for the test and can as well be removed.

Change-Id: I54cb4fdf74dd7174450dcc552b077d388dbac749
2023-03-01 08:54:11 -06:00
Arlo Breault 1dd994a28a Re-enable test
Change-Id: I9c909e10170a0437676bdf1290cc6421073a8284
Follow-Up: If9cdabdfac26656272fcf3b4aaae0576aaed1346
Depends-On: If1e55feb86ce8b32f772e3b78bc9d29f122f4d58
2023-02-09 17:30:52 -05:00
Arlo Breault 5fa75277b7 Disable test for CI
Needed-By: If1e55feb86ce8b32f772e3b78bc9d29f122f4d58
Change-Id: If9cdabdfac26656272fcf3b4aaae0576aaed1346
2023-02-09 17:28:08 -05:00
Arlo Breault d5b5a83ae9 Sync up Cite repo with Parsoid
This now aligns with Parsoid commit b520b8092db6f092603e7244cdac5f1fc645e89a

Change-Id: I671c5831d90bbeb088f5ff2133df553142e1af53
2023-02-09 16:58:34 -05:00
Arlo Breault 0060e2b43d Sync up with Parsoid citeParserTests.txt
This now aligns with Parsoid commit 9041d0bac69fe763112c0d8fcbd553a211a25c26

Change-Id: I34b1fdf2232e67db5326ed25ab3f4ad128e59e5d
2022-08-23 15:11:06 -04:00
Thiemo Kreuz 8fef0dd2aa Improve two error messages
Makes it easier to find the source of the error in the wikitext.

Change-Id: I648a19881210184ab1abe9b948b5efbbbdabcdc9
2022-08-20 12:23:28 +02:00
Subramanya Sastry 5515de2003 Sync up with Parsoid citeParserTests.txt
This now aligns with Parsoid commit e4305217923162568cf5b6ec08ba3c96fd5b04e3

Change-Id: I935d8641d90ec5cbcf7d29fd984085cc5338b6ec
2022-05-17 18:00:18 -05:00
Subramanya Sastry 45cc963ca2 Sync up with Parsoid citeParserTests.txt
This now aligns with Parsoid commit 12d896bd5852b4a7d602fb22dd09d7fc2c5c5b64

Change-Id: I1d3183ee4afa37e0d71768cd02f03112771b82c4
2022-05-11 18:08:24 -05:00
Subramanya Sastry a478d6c3a3 Sync up with Parsoid citeParserTests.txt
This now aligns with Parsoid commit c434df9.

Change-Id: Ib8b8593d1a303530dac56ed01335e0d635863eda
2022-04-20 19:03:18 -04:00
Subramanya Sastry 169ebf6344 Sync up with Parsoid citeParserTests.txt
This now aligns with Parsoid commit 3b5a7a318eaf8dcc5e6ed142352f1cf1a9439474

Change-Id: I32f9fcac231cdf25bd1501d7f6e022e067c8d8e1
2022-04-14 12:15:53 +05:30
Subramanya Sastry ed59e2ac38 Sync up with Parsoid citeParserTests.txt
This now aligns with Parsoid commit 29f8e7051529ecbb62fc52bff6726a4df8bf20c2

Change-Id: I165ee24e1b78bdf181fa45430fdec1549310c359
2021-09-30 15:00:56 -05:00
C. Scott Ananian 53e8dc7b39 Sync up with Parsoid citeParserTests.txt
This now aligns with Parsoid commit 88d4620278988d121761fb440952d1d66a70ce99

Required some newline fixes to resync after "Refactor newline logic"
(change I6691c70f8e3fa3f21e2d11035bed9cdc2dc87093 /
commit 6389459b1e) was merged
this morning.

Change-Id: I64fba6cc9330a55d4e1eeb5371164b3eb4efa508
2021-07-30 11:14:38 -04:00
C. Scott Ananian 6b813c6874 Sync up with Parsoid citeParserTests.txt
This now aligns with Parsoid commit d9a3e14dfcb422e95de7a79f0eb662fd43f9354f

Change-Id: Iae34d2107bfb47304819da7f7c715dec83da1a48
2020-08-18 16:54:33 -04:00
C. Scott Ananian a0faedb942 Sync up with Parsoid citeParserTests.txt
This now aligns with Parsoid commit 77db605163990ad851e3da0fb4fa7eca2081f379

Change-Id: I19ad9f1b6845e5557c2f5f87ac435db0ad87000d
2020-07-28 15:53:08 -04:00
C. Scott Ananian 90728bde87 Sync up with Parsoid citeParserTests.txt
This now aligns with Parsoid commit 7321ab547b7663ba86c1cfe0bc021ff1918c0970

Change-Id: I2cc88069b19e7611f23c83ca993f9caa70f786f0
2020-07-15 11:39:46 -04:00
Thiemo Kreuz 7fbd5de7f5 Merge two code paths related to follow
This patch also adds a test case that was missing before. If a
follow="…" is followed by another, normal <ref>, the internal key
(a.k.a. $this->refSequence) is not incremented. This was the case
before, just not covered by any test.

Change-Id: I102d1e67a6918017acc7e4a4663b08c828d101a6
2020-05-12 10:52:08 +02:00
Subramanya Sastry eb8e07c69c Sync up with Parsoid citeParserTests.txt
This now aligns with Parsoid commit 1e72ddefc2df8d5b38d7b370d67a87b48d8a09f7

Change-Id: Ic75ac33c92997427751d037339f7eb79027356a2
2020-05-07 12:14:19 -05:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 3678215a77 Add a newline in wikitext before autogenerated reflist
Previously the reflist was added at the end of the last line of text,
which messes up paragraph wrapping (as seen in many test cases), and
generated invalid HTML when the last line was a list item (T148701).

(second try, previously reverted in 8c933d03c5)

Note this affects only pages where the <references /> tag is missing,
and the references section is auto-generated at the very end of the page.

Bug: T148701
Change-Id: Ib2101346434a4e317b5fc7379215b60c7020cb2b
2020-05-06 20:51:25 +02:00
C. Scott Ananian 376c0418d3 Update parser tests to v2 (tidy by default)
The most common cleanup required by switching to tidy output was adding
missing <p>-wrappers to the last item before <references/>.

Bug: T246285
Change-Id: I7c8a08c4e6eff7caf4539a26fae475a4133f9a0c
2020-04-01 11:11:13 -04:00
Awight 8c933d03c5 Revert "Add a newline in wikitext before autogenerated reflist"
This reverts commit 90697ffe43.

Change-Id: I659ce1689603fd16e378fb8d3d5bd6d1089342b2
2020-04-01 08:03:55 +00:00
Bartosz Dziewoński 90697ffe43 Add a newline in wikitext before autogenerated reflist
Previously the reflist was added at the end of the last line of text,
which messes up paragraph wrapping (as seen in many test cases), and
generated invalid HTML when the last line was a list item (T148701).

Bug: T148701
Change-Id: Ifc873fc913e717026d80d54b570c594d1073fb42
2020-03-31 19:00:51 +00:00
Thiemo Kreuz 48e2f02e20 Add two extreme follow edge cases back to parser tests
This reverts parts of the revert I3bee35f, which reverted a3d312c8.
I believe it's helpful to keep these test cases just to document how
the code currently behaves. I removed all TODO because we don't know
if and how we want to touch this again.

Bug: T240858
Change-Id: Ib91acfcb7292e5c03ce9cc4d7be782085e10aa27
2020-02-05 15:04:49 +01:00
Adam Wight f2bd6b6dcc Revert "Standardize "follow" validation"
This reverts commit a3d312c8f4.

Bug: T240858
Change-Id: I3bee35f27797a04c41c265f7e598d8383414b67a
2020-02-05 11:42:28 +01:00
Adam Wight a3d312c8f4 Standardize "follow" validation
Perform the validation in validateRef, and display a new error message for
broken "follow" refs.  This changes existing behavior, where broken folow
ref content is arbitrarily displayed at the top of the references list and
no error is rendered.

Thanks to weasely wording, the new error can later be reused for "extends"
errors.

Bug: T240858
Change-Id: I506e4dcd1151671f5302ecd99581145d979d8124
2020-01-30 17:25:42 +00:00
jenkins-bot 3c8a225052 Merge "Fix incomplete rollback producing bad footnote numbers" 2020-01-24 15:11:31 +00:00
Thiemo Kreuz 2ddc6f133b Fix incomplete rollback producing bad footnote numbers
Bug: T48140
Change-Id: I53ce5d8488d4c24d6f23f6f0e70806d7db4064e1
2020-01-24 13:02:53 +01:00
Thiemo Kreuz 816b1b0add Remove newline characters from all error messages
These create bogus output, depending on the surrounding wikitext the
<ref> tag is used in. For example, this example wikitext:

* Example.<ref name="1">a</ref> More text.

… will be rendered with the "More text" sentence wrapped on the next
line, outside of the list. However, this does *not* happen in many of
the localizations, e.g. German, because many Tanslatewiki translators
did not copied the bogus \n. Why should they.

TL;DR: These newline characters either do nothing, or destroy the output.
In both cases the proper fix is to replace them with spaces.

Some of the test cases touched in this patch demonstrate the issue.

Change-Id: I395a40637a5293eda1f477963d252ce1a215f8b2
2020-01-24 12:29:14 +01:00
Thiemo Kreuz 9565d6e887 Resolve a TODO by covering it with a test case
It turns out this is indeed necessary. The test demonstrates why.

Change-Id: Id9c6a48f72ef8d3f0cc9a714d826418e69913b0a
2020-01-21 10:11:03 +00:00
Adam Wight b3ea9f4ef8 Relax empty-string name validation
Allow a ref with `name=""` for backwards-compatibility.
Partially reverts I07738cce2641026dfaa92ba263ed6f9834be0944

Bug: T242437
Change-Id: Iaed2d1c41be377a4961aff39838b0965f6c00616
2020-01-20 12:40:09 +00:00
Arlo Breault 7e2bbae4c2 Sync up with Parsoid citeParserTests.txt
This now aligns with Parsoid commit 0a6c576ad6ccfc81c2bfa20757417c62e554ef56

Change-Id: Ifa5d60e362e5c530d12d3b94351aef2d1b1962cc
2020-01-17 14:51:03 -05:00
Adam Wight f3031b80b9 Fix for blank-named ref in #tag
A fun edge case where `name=""` fools both validation branches after
a references rollback, and triggered a LogicException.  Stop these
freak refs.

Bug: T242437
Change-Id: I07738cce2641026dfaa92ba263ed6f9834be0944
2020-01-17 11:19:29 +01:00
Adam Wight 1c947a808d Fix for nested #tag:references
It's possible to nest <references> by using tricky constructs like the
{{#tag function, and this breaks our rollback logic.  Try to show normal
output, otherwise show an error.

Includes regression tests.

Bug: T242437
Change-Id: I33e497cdf8508ce7ccb7f0f315c00af5eee47d0e
2020-01-15 12:44:29 +01:00
jenkins-bot 45119f8c61 Merge "Move "dir" error handling to validation" 2019-12-19 10:18:24 +00:00
Arlo Breault 6d55f9e8cc Sync up with Parsoid citeParserTests.txt
This now aligns with Parsoid commit 41f397ce4d563fa7f7770725d88944dcabda4116

Change-Id: I27b7f035c8b99ca80501b8cd1169ed8c8895ef93
2019-12-18 15:30:49 -05:00
Adam Wight 1e82f8f073 Move "dir" error handling to validation
Note that this patch changes behavior, an invalid "dir" will result in
a cite reference at the point where the <ref> is declared rather than
in the references section.  This is consistent with other errors.

Bug: T15673
Change-Id: Id10db40aa0b391f2f1d9274aa09d22a7278d65e3
2019-12-18 10:05:59 +01:00
Thiemo Kreuz 1bd66081f7 Fix inconsistent error reporting for invisible content
This makes one of the last remaining edge-cases about non-empty, but
non-visible content (a <ref> that only contains whitespace) behave
identical to all other places. We already reported it as being empty
everywhere else, except inside of <references>.

Note that the test cases look like they are reporting the same errors
twice. But this is not the case:

The first set of errors is about <ref name="…"> inside of <references>
not having visible content. This should always be reported, even if the
<ref> got content from somewhere else on the page.

The second set of errors is when a <ref name="…"> *never* got any
content.

This patch will slightly increase the numbers of errors reported.

Change-Id: I4a156aa9e466f735d92fe0ba5cc0678ec8bbdd50
2019-12-17 13:37:01 +01:00
Thiemo Kreuz 2cb7e5d438 Add test cases for duplicate <references> with same group
Change-Id: I9603e7ebf167330b1eddae1676e9234edf6557bc
2019-12-02 15:08:15 +00:00
Thiemo Kreuz 99d23ac841 Remove redundant attribute trimming
We noticed the group="…" attribute was the only one that was not
trimmed. Does this mean it was possible to have two groups "a" and
" a"? It turns out: no. This was never possible because the parser
already trims all attributes before calling this code.

I tried to come up with the worst possible test case, but it succeeds,
even with very old versions of this codebase.

I suggest to remove the extra trimming from this codebase and rely on
what the parser provides.

Note the content is special and *not* trimmed by default.

Change-Id: Idff015447d7156ba7b5c03a5c423f199a71349f2
2019-11-27 12:12:51 +00:00
Adam Wight 8453e3ecd7 Extract stack and state to a new class
Most of this state is used to manage interactions with other state,
and encapsulation allows us to hide data structures and access behind
self-explanatory function names.

The interface is still much wider than I'd like, but it can be improved in
future work.

There is one small behavior change in here: in the `follows` edge case
demonstrated by I3bdf26fd14, we prepend if the splice point cannot be
used because it has a non-numeric key.  I believe this was the original
intention of the logic, and is how the numeric case behaves.  I've verified
that when array_splice throws a warning about non-numeric key, it fails to
add anything to the original array, so the broken follows ref disappeared.

Bug: T237241
Change-Id: I091a0b71ee9aa78e841c2e328018e886a7217715
2019-11-25 14:06:32 +01:00
Subramanya Sastry 2cfb76f8b6 Sync up with Parsoid citeParserTests.txt
This now aligns with Parsoid commit 7dfc2e931a6afeb62d2a0d791cda88fd8d39c070

Change-Id: I7edd1f293530653ae1bbfe47028e585f2b46927b
2019-11-22 18:44:22 +00:00
jenkins-bot 7f4cff9523 Merge "Move bad dir="…" error reporting down to the renderer" 2019-11-22 13:46:44 +00:00
Thiemo Kreuz 8e42a6ecdf Add missing test cases for follow="…"
One of the test cases was duplicated, but a lot of the possible code
paths never had tests, including the happy code path!

I found this issue while trying to rework some of the more confusing
loops in this codebase. These changes are still part of this patch. All
loops still do the same as before, but are (I hope) more readable now.

Bug: T238187
Change-Id: I85baeadd9b149025a14c7522bcc4182339c66972
2019-11-22 11:32:28 +01:00
Thiemo Kreuz ea6cea93ed Move bad dir="…" error reporting down to the renderer
… and make the error message for bad dir="…" shorter and more to the
point.

Now I understand why the error reporting was not done when $text was
empty: the error was actually appended to $text, which messes with
everything else that also works with the $text variable! This even
includes the API. This error message was exposed via the API. That was
certainly a bug.

With this patch, all error checking for the dir="…" attribute is now
done way down, when rendering the <references> section.

Note this also fixes a bug where the dir="…" was *not* rendered when
previewing a section.

Change-Id: I4ab0cb510973ed879c606bfaa394aacc91129854
2019-11-22 10:07:28 +01:00
Thiemo Kreuz b10dd4ec27 Block de-facto empty <ref> as if it's empty
The use case we care about is this:
<ref extends="some_book"> </ref>

It doesn't make sense that works, but the following doesn't:
<ref extends="some_book"></ref>

We decided that both need to behave the same.

For consistency this patch is applying the same change to all references,
no matter if they use the extends attribute or not. This is an actual
change and might make existing wikitext render differently. However, I
would like to argue that all wikitext that was using this was broken. The
effect of a <ref> </ref> with some whitespace is that the <references>
section at the end of the article will contain – well – an empty footnote.

Bug: T237241
Change-Id: Iaee35583eabcb416b0a06849b89ebbfb0fb7fef9
2019-11-20 15:07:54 +00:00
Adam Wight 0ebf86fdf3 Split out BookReferencing parser tests
Encapsulate the feature tests in dedicated files.  These are picked
up by the test runner for matching glob `tests/parser/*.txt`, as can
be shown by,

  phpunit.php --testsuite parsertests --filter=bookRef

Also adds TODO comments to some tests, documenting how the current output
will not match the fully implemented code's results.

Bug: T236256
Change-Id: Ie3e769c84856256180754aeff417da893a84b479
2019-11-08 10:02:38 +01:00
Andrew Kostka 1dcb096776 Add parser tests for refined references as rendered right now
These tests document the current status quo, and are meant to change
with every patch that makes the code for refined references more
feature complete.

Bug: T236256
Change-Id: I8c11b1decc36b86e7f7d1919cc39d0c16a200055
2019-11-08 09:38:08 +01:00
Adam Wight 5e8d48b331 Minimal support for bookreferencing tag
Allows the "refines" attribute when the feature flag is set, but doesn't
render.  This is part of our rollback strategy, so that we aren't left
with invalid wikitext in case of undeployment.

Bug: T236257
Change-Id: I936be0e62dccb46caeb84162d2c5166956fd9916
2019-10-24 12:24:36 +00:00