The following sniffs are failing and were disabled:
* MediaWiki.Commenting.FunctionComment.MissingDocumentationPublic
Change-Id: I6075c76d53a899aac56af027f9a956a6b9e6a667
Protected effectively means "public to subclasses" and should be
avoided for the same reasons as marking everything as public should
be avoided.
Change-Id: Iba674b486ce53fd1f94f70163d47824e969abb77
This commit adds a class AFPSyntaxChecker which can statically analyze
a filter code to detect the following errors:
- unbound variables (which comes in two modes: conservative and liberal,
default to conservative)
- unused variables (disabled by default for compatibilty)
- assignment on built-in identifiers
- function application's arity mismatch
- function application's invalid function name
- non-string literal in the first argument of set / set_var
The existing parser and evaluator are modified as follows:
- The new (caching) evaluator no longer needs to perform variable
hoisting at runtime.
- Note that for array assignment, this changes the semantics.
- The new parser is more lenient, reducing parsing errors.
The static analyzer will catch these errors instead, allowing us
to give a much better error message and reduces the complexity of
the parser.
* The parser now allows function name to be any identifier.
* The parser now allows arity mismatch to occur.
* The parser now allows the first argument of set to be any expression.
Concretely, obvious changes that users will see are:
1. a := [1]; false & (a[] := 2); a[0] === 1
would evaluate to true, while it used to evaluate to the undefined value
due to hoisting
2. f(1)
will now error with 'f is not a valid function' as opposed to
'Unexpected "T_BRACE"'
3. length
will now error with 'Illegal use of built-in identifier "length"'
as opposed to 'Expected a ('
Appendix: conservative and liberal mode
The conservative mode is completely compatible with the current evaluator.
That is,
false & (a := 1); a
will not deem `a` as unbound, though this is actually undesirable because
`a` would then be bound to the troublesome undefined value.
The liberal mode rejects the above pattern by deeming `a` as unbound.
However, it also rejects
true & (a := 1); a
even though (a := 1) is always executed. Since there are several filters
in Wikimedia projects that rely on this behavior, we default the mode
to conservative for now.
Note that even the liberal mode doesn't really respect lexical scope
appeared in some other programming languages (see also T234690).
For instance:
(if true then (a := 1) else (a := 2) end); a
would be accepted by the liberal checker, even though under lexical scope,
`a` would be unbound. However, it is unlikely that lexical scope
will be suitable for the filter language, as most filters in
Wikimedia projects that have user-defined variable do violate lexical scope.
Bug: T260903
Bug: T238709
Bug: T237610
Bug: T234690
Bug: T231536
Change-Id: Ic6d030503e554933f8d220c6f87b680505918ae2
Create a dedicated "Exception" sub-namespace and remove the "AFP"
prefix, a leftover from the pre-namespace era.
Change-Id: I7e5fded9316d8b7d1628bc1a6ba8b1879ac901e1
All methods were moved to the new parser. Tests and other pieces were
adjusted to expect just a single parser. There are still some TODOs
(remove AFPTransitionBase, remove $this->mCur), but these are left for
another commit.
Note that the new parser was not renamed: this is because the names are
wrong anyway (CachingParser is more of an Evaluator than a Parser, and
AFPTreeParser is the real parser, and should be renamed as well).
NOTE to reviewers: this patch looks quite big, but if you diff the old
parser with the new version of the CachingParser, you'll notice that the
diff is actually small, since everything was basically copied verbatim.
Bug: T239990
Change-Id: Ie914ef64c70503a201b4d2dec698ca2fa8e69b10
1 - Change the structure of if/elseif for readability
2 - In the old parser, if there's an empty argument, never add it (the
new parser was already doing that).
Bug: T156095
Bug: T156096
Change-Id: I4237b1a0ba01e7ce04dcc945f7daf34612fcf07d
